Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

Separation Anxiety - how on Earth do you deal with it?

3 replies

Willsmum79 · 02/12/2012 15:20

My son is 11 months old. He will not allow me to leave his sight and sometimes his side when he's playing on the carpet without having a full on screaming fit! He is very clingy and even if I put him in his walker whilst I'm pottering around, he sometimes tugs (happily) on my trousers but if he suspects I'm going to leave his vision, there is a look of panic on his face. I can't even go to the loo without him having a meltdown even if he can see me!
I understand this to be separation anxiety and I know it to be a normal development step children go through but how on Earth do you deal with it? Should I let him cry or do i pick him up and cuddle him every time he cries? A colleague of mine warned me not to keep picking him up but reassure him with my voice. The basis of her advice was because a mutual colleague and friend (we work in a primary school) has a son who had a severe 'case' of SA when he was a baby/toddler and has had a lot of problems settling at school and dealing with change. I'm not sure what to do for the best.
My mum cares for him 2 days a week and the childminder the other 3 days. My DH and childminder suspect that my mum mollycoddles him a lot (which I must admit, he always seems to be in her arms one way or another) and gives him 1:1 constantly whereas their thinking is that some of the time he should spend independently playing with his toys. He cries when he goes to the childminder and will cling to me on Wednesdays (in fact everyday) and the childminder reports that he clings to her most of Wednesdays but by Friday he's a lot better. I know he likes going to the childminder because when DH picks him up he is playing and very smiley and happy. He has also taken to clinging to me when anyone comes to visit including his paternal grandparents who visit every week/ The last two Sundays he has cried when handed to his grandma and on one occasion stopped breathing because he got himself so worked up. He would interact with them from his highchair or walker or when held by me but refused to be held by them which is odd and a new one on me!! But ... he is fine with my mum!!
Is it kind to be cruel or just plain cruel and attend to his every cry, demand and whim???

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Sarah2828 · 02/12/2012 15:38

I know exactly what you're going through as my 11 month old is quite the same at the moment. First I'd like to say congratulations - separation anxiety is a very normal, healthy and important developmental phase in a baby's life. It shows that the baby has a secure attachment to their mother, which means that the mum has done a great job! This phase will pass, and in the meantime I think you can help your baby most if you give him as much reassurance as he needs. It is said that the babies who were allowed to be as dependent as they needed will be the most independent children later on. I don't believe you can cuddle a baby too much, it is what babies need to become independent little creatures later on. It can be a really tough time for the mum though.. There's a great blog post written by BabyCalm founder Sarah Ockwell-Smith about how to cope with separation anxiety which really helped me: babycalm.wordpress.com/2012/11/11/how-to-cope-when-your-baby-has-separation-anxiety-aka-the-clingy-baby/

Also, have you heard about the Wonder Weeks? In a baby's 20 first months of life there are phases of great fussiness when the baby makes a huge developmental leap. This is the time when the baby acts severely clingy. These phases pass after a couple of weeks though. I can recommend the Wonder Weeks book or website for tips about how to cope with these difficult weeks. www.thewonderweeks.com/

Please don't think you cuddle your baby too much. The way you help your baby most is to attend to his cries. Like this you'll help him learn to trust the world and become an independent person. Listen to your heart and instincts, we know very well what our babies need! xx

Willsmum79 · 26/12/2012 19:47

Thank you.

I have Wonder Weeks and it is a 'wonder'ful book!

He has just started to crawl in the last two weeks and seems to be less clingy (cries less when I move away from him) but he has become very, very cuddly in the last few weeks - his attempts to climb mount Everest and to have rough and tumble is my guess!

OP posts:
AngelDog · 26/12/2012 21:54

Totally normal - he needs you to give him the reassurance he needs.

A sling is great - stick him in a back carry and you may be able to get on with things.

IME separation anxiety is really common, but those who have it badly e.g. my DS continue to have it because that's the sort of personality they have, not because parents have 'mollycoddled' them.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page