@ Rowood: There is no need to apologise for feeling the way you do. Its hard with a newborn. I think you are completely right for wanting a routine. Its normal to want to make things more ordered so that such a demanding situation is more manageable.
@ All the other posts: you have all been a bit harsh. A little bit of sympathy is needed, I feel. Rowood asked for constructive help and advice.
I have a 4 week old and have been feeding on demand and sleeping on demand too (if that phrase exists). Both me and my husband are at the end of our tether. He has gone off to work with one hour sleep after I 'hogged' the sleeping luxury last night. I was crying while feeding a couple of days ago due to exhaustion and the relentlessness of all it all. This is NOT healthy for anyone, especially our daughter.
So I completely understand your wanting a routine. I am trying to get one in place. By routine I mean a general time for doing the same thing every day - not stopwatch timing. Face it life with a newborn is like groundhog day anyway and having no social life at all makes it easier.
Here is my 'routine' that I still trying to estabilsh and will need constant revision of course:
midnight: feed
3 am: feed
6 am: feed
during this time, baby sleeps in cot or in bed with us. Luckily our daughter is like clockwork at night...thank god!!!
6 am - 9 am: get out of bed depending on how much sleep
Then a cycle of feeding/'playing' (looking at stuff, doing housework with baby in carrier, watching telly together)/trying to get her to nap (ha ha ha!!!). Try to feed every 2-3 hours. Try desparately to get dressed, showered and eat during this time. Working on improving baby's self-soothing skills so that I can do these things.
Afternoon walk (1-4 pm roughly): this is essential for me and my sanity. Going shopping, go to the library, go for cup of tea. Baby sleeps and may have one feed during this.
Another cycle of feeding/playing/napping until 7 pm.
Feed on demand until baby falls asleep usually 9-10 ish, but has been later.
Feeding on demand was doing my head in. My little girl fights sleep and so gets grumpy very easily. I was mistaking overtiredness for hunger, which led to her snacking all the time...bloody exhausting. It was not working for us.
I admit that I have read the Baby Whispherer and found it very helpful. I have cherry-picked the bits that work for our little family. Its still in the early stages, but I mentally need a semblance of a routine for my mental health. I do not ever want to be at the stage where I am crying while singing a lullaby.
One of the posters said that 'driving me up the wall' was an odd turn of phrase. I consider it to be better than 'wishing I had not had my daughter', which has gone through my mind a few times. I am taking steps to ensure that I enjoy my time with my daughter and that her, me and my husband are happy in this new adventure together.
I think that every child, parent and situation is different. There is no absolute right and wrong way of doing things. It is the responsibility of the parent to take others' advice and adapt it so that it suits you and your child. Feeding on demand will work for some and not for others.
@ Rowood: Good luck and I hope that it gets easier :)