Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

When are tantrums no longer "acceptable"?

5 replies

DrFish · 21/02/2012 09:43

Looking for advice - my DS has always had mega tantrums, like, an hour of screaming and ranting if he can't have what he wants. Normal, for some dcs I guess. But, he will soon be 9 and I can't believe we're still dealing with this. The meltdowns are not as frequent and don't go on for as long these days, so he is obviously maturing. We have had to be so firm with the important boundaries as he basically pushes as hard as he can against all the boundaries we put in place, BUT, I would say that he now knows that what me and DH say is what ultimately goes, and there will be a consequence for disobedience.

However, we still get a LOT of crying and screaming when things are not the way he wants, and I'm wondering if we should "work" on that, iyswim. I think maybe he needs to learn how to ask for what he wants in a nice way, and sometimes just to accept that he can't have it all his way, without a big fuss. For example, he knows that he has to do homework before he is allowed to go out and play. He is very dreamy so the homework can take longer than it should, but yesterday he finished in time to go outside before dinner. I said he could go, but that he needed to come back in 15 minutes as dinner would be ready. Immediate crying and complaining and saying "you're just evil". Should I ignore him (as I've done in the past when he was younger), or should there be consequence for his behaviour? I think he should be controlling his anger a bit better now, and (if appropriate to negotiate), learning to negotiate in a polite way.

Any advice appreciated!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
daytoday · 21/02/2012 10:46

On the information given, my first thought is, that he did his homework, followed instructions and he still only got 15 mins to play? 15 mins is nothing.

Couldn't you have rewarded and highlighted the positive behaviour by saying 'you did so well at your homework tonight, that although dinner is ready in 15 mins I will let you play for 30mins and keep it warm. Well done.'

DrFish · 21/02/2012 11:04

He can play again after dinner too, but they know what time dinner is and he needs to be here. I might have kept it dinner warm but the whole can't necessarily revolve around him, AND I think at his age he should speak normally to me and not just scream.

OP posts:
DrFish · 21/02/2012 11:06

the whole family, should say

OP posts:
deaconblue · 21/02/2012 14:30

My ds has as and would really struggle in your inflexible household and would scream and tantrum. I call ds for dinner, he says 'can I just finish making this Lego thing' and I say yes. As adults we are rarely expected to stop something we are enjoying without warning. If a child is absorbed in their play it only seems fair to me to give them a chance to finish off. Do you give him five minute warnings etc?
I agree by 9 I would hope ds would speak to me nicely but I think you need to look at why he is so cross rather than thinking he 'should' be better iyswim

daytoday · 21/02/2012 14:40

I do understand that set routines are good for everyone, however, whatever you are doing is not working is it? Of course your son shouldn't be exploding but something is not working here. Do you think your approach could be softened? I mean, it wouldn't be the end of the world if you had delayed tea by 15 mins, would it?

I am just saying, when I am trying to encourage a good sort of behaviour I reward that behaviour massively and in a very OTT way - this is just a technique to highlight and encourage what I want and to instill confidence in my children to do things by themselves.

Somewhere, somehow you have got in a rut - where your son rude and you have dug your heels in because you have had enough. Its a no win situation, he'll be upset with you and you'll be upset with him.

What's the point in him doing his homework before tea if he doesn't get to play anyway?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page