Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

sibling rivalry driving family apart - help!

6 replies

123Jersey · 04/11/2010 23:58

DS is 9 and has never really taken to DD who is 5. He is agressive if he doesn't get his own way, when asked to do something, refuses saying 'she isn't doing it', he manipulates her to do things he should do (putting his clothes away, picking things up,etc). He trashes her room, and then refuses to tidy it up, was this evening little event.

He is never wrong, it is never him, always someone else, he argues, is sly and lies (we know this, as his lips move!) and to be frank, I am at the stage where I don't want to be with him. Not bad for a nine year old!

We have tried giving him special time with both me and his dad (both one on one, and the three of us), and to be fair, when he is on his own, he is great company. We've tried to give him responsibility (chores) and appropriate rewards, but he just looses interest, then it is a fight to get him to do his jobs.

When I've discussed his behaviour with him, his response is either 'it's her, not me', or 'you love her more than me'. Hubby and I have tried explaining that she is 5 and has different needs, but we love them both; she doesn't get to go watch the rugby in the rain Grin.

During the last half term he went on a day camp, but unfortunately she couldn't go as there was not room. He didn't like this, and said he wanted to be here too, unfortunately, as his behaviour during the summer holidays was so bad, and I would be on my own during half term, there was no way I was looking after them both. He just couldn't grasp that his behaviour has consequences.

There is no happiness in our house, no joy. I can't remember a day when I haven't shouted at them (perhaps even screamed) at them to do things (stop arguing, tidy their rooms, brush their teeth, eat tidily, don't hurt the cat, don't hurt each other).

Sometimes after I have dropped them off at school, I want to just go. Just keep going, turn left, instead of right, and go. I feel like I have made a terrible mistake in having children, I am a terrible mum, and that they deserve better.

OP posts:
anonymosity · 05/11/2010 01:14

I think rather than looking at it as sibling rivalry to tackle, you might want to look at unacceptable behaviour and address that.

What happens when he trashes her room? Do you tidy it up if he refuses, or do you take a stand, ask him to help you and explain that if he doesn't, privileges will be lost (tv / computer game / whathave you).

I do believe if you deal with one thing at a time, you will improve the behaviour. At the moment, the rivalry seems to be an excuse that's being used (by him, possibly also by you) not to correct it. I don't mean that to sound harsh at all, just objective.

Joolyjoolyjoo · 05/11/2010 01:21

I do feel for you, but I'm not sure it actually rivalry just siblings!

I have 3- they are 6, 5 and 3, and they are also driving me mad with their constant squabbling and "it wasn't me- it was him/ her!!" Any mess is always the fault of one of the others, who then says it wasn't them, etc etc etc. Very tiring. I also find it upsetting as I was an only child who yearned for siblings, and I can't believe how horrible they are to one another. DH, who has a sister, says it is par for the course.

I usually deal with it by enforcing seperation! They all get sent to various rooms and told to stay away from each other. Funny thing is, they hate that, as they are actually all quite fond of one another- go figure!

piprabbit · 05/11/2010 01:34

Take a bit of time to explore the Parentchannel.tv website. You might want to start with this clip:
www.parentchannel.tv/video/i-dont-my-child

But there are loads of other about setting consistent boundaries for the family here and squabbling siblings.

I hope some it helps - I've always found it useful to sit and watch and get some new ideas.

fleacircus · 05/11/2010 08:53

'Siblings Without Rivalry' is a really irritating but extremely useful book - and very quick to read. My two are much younger than yours but I swear by it already.

glasscompletelybroken · 05/11/2010 10:17

My DD2 was so jealous and infuriated by the arrival of DD3 that I really couldn't leave them in a room together for 5 minutes without worrying that she would actually kill her sister!

I tried leaving DD3 with a friend once a week and having regular one to one time with DD2 but it didn't really have any effect.

The antagonism continued all through childhood and adolescence and only really changed when they were both into their late teens.

Now they are unbelievably close - not sure how that happened!

All I would say to you is - it's not your fault and it's nothing you're doing wrong. it's just the way it is.

I also agree with anonymosity in that you have to tackle the behaviour and make sure there are consequences to his actions. Keep reinforcing that you love them both equally but that you won't tolerate bad behaviour from either of them.

123Jersey · 05/11/2010 10:29

Thank you all so much for your comments. I really do appreciate them, and no, Anon, you don't sound harsh, just realistic!

No, to those who asked whether I tied up the room - he did it, and was then sent to bed for his behaviour (he hit her again).

I will try (again) the 'special time', and will keep in mind your comments about dealing with the behaviour, rather than the 'label'. I liked the 'siblings, rather than rivalry' comments; makes sense in the light of day.

I will check out those resources as well.

Feeling much better, thanks again.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page