Madeline, Imogen or Isla?

[tessofthedurbervilles]

Which one is best? Like them all.....

The first two are more common round this way.

No Isla's though.

All are nice.

I also like Ailsa

All nice. I think I would go for Imogen or Isla.

Like them all - that's not helpful is it

I do like MAdeleine and I do like Isla. Lovely.

Not keen on Imogen.

Imogen nice. Not keen on the other two.

Imogen

I like Imogen best.

I always think of Isla Sinclair when I hear Isla.

I prefer Madeleine spelt with 3 e's.

who cares if a load of old 40-somethings think of Isal st clair She was quite foxy in her day

My DDs middle name is Imogen. I love it. It is popular, but there aren't really that many of them around. Imogen was the perfect Shakespearian princess in Cymbeline.

Madeleine is lovely, but has been rather tainted by Madeleine McCann.

Isla is very pretty. I know one in England. Think it is more popular in Scotland. Dunno about Isla StWotsit. I think of Isla Fisher, the pretty redhead who was in Home & Away and is engaged to Sacha Baron Cohen.

I have a Madeleine but had considered calling her Isla so love them both.

Isla is gorgeous

LOVE the name Isla

not keen on the others

I like Imogen, I wanted to use it but as our surname begins with an I it sounded very odd. The other names are nice, but Imogen is lovely.

A friend in America (Brit abroad) and my best friend's sister in law have both had baby girls in the last month and both called them Isla.

Pretty name but I predict will become the next Grace or Ruby in popularity. If this kind of thing matters to you, I would go for Madeleine (not a big fan of Imogen although DH loves it).

There are loads of Maddies around so although I like it would put me off.

I find Imogen a bit difficult to say/ a bit of a mouthful can't imagine shouting it in Tescos!

Love Isla and also think of Isla Fisher not sinclair. Know that there are a few around but don't know any around here.

I am not a 40 somthing, thankyou, pointy!!!!!

And yes Isla Sinclair was atractive (I presume she still is)and had a lovely voice.

I still prefer Imogen.

ok ok, the 50 somethings too

Imogen
Isla
Madeline

... in that order

All lovely names though

Pointy...for your information, I am 22.

Isla very, very common here in scotland....bit of a yawn when you hear of another one tbh

like Imogen

I've never yawned when I've heard someone's name.

I like them all. Dd has a friend called Imogen who is lovely and kind. She is the best dancer in dd1's dance scool. You would think (ime anyway) that this would mean that she is all stuck up and false smiles etc but no she is a genuinely lovely little girl who is a really talented dancer. That's why i like that name.

How do you pronounce Isla?

Aila (as in Island)?
Or Eesla (German pronounciation)?