I always think this, as much as I love giving my opinions which I have no idea how helpful they are, I think why would anyone do this to themselves?! People have such wildly different experiences of names - miserable aunt, school bully, favourite grandma, favourite movie star, evil character from a book, stripper, Irish, Welsh, Scottish, Cornish, traditionalists, country music fans, contemporary fans, nature lovers, star lovers, London dwelling, France dwelling, International school etc etc etc.
I think unless it's particularly unusual, or perhaps if you are choosing a name not of your own culture, or is the name of someone very famous like Donald or Taylor or something, opinions are so madly varied I can't believe it's much help and must just ruin some peoples love of a name.
It is fun though, and I love seeing all the latest trends and ideas! Particularly liked the Cornish thread recently.