Choice of 3 girl names

[glasshalffull0]

We’re not finding out the gender of this baby and have boy name sorted but cannot agree or decide between 3 girl names, we change our mind every day! Baby will have a big sister called Rosie

Eliza
Lily
Molly

Rosie and Molly

Lily is too flowery with your DD

Molly and Eliza both lovely, I think Eliza sounds nicest as a pair

Rosie and Molly.

Kindly, I wouldn’t take any advice from randos on the internet, wait and see if it even is a girl and then decide what she looks most like.
But if I had to pick one, I’d throw a curve ball and suggest Lila. To have 2 ‘flower’ names may be a bit twee when they are older, and Molly just gives Molly-Mae vibes for me. Sorry.
That is just me though, and I am just one of the aforementioned randos 😊

Agree with PP to avoid both having flower names. I know someone whose girls both have gemstone names and it’s not so cute a secondary school age!

Molly is a name of a drug I believe, and it’s also very similar to what German speakers call an overweight person (although this might not be so relevant here but as a German speaker it’s always the first thing that comes to mind when I see this name).

I slightly prefer the name Molly, but I think Eliza 'goes best' with Rosie.

Eliza - it's lovely. Goes well with Rosie too.

Molly and Lily are nice enough though (although too many Lilys over the last few decades). Eliza is more of a solid name though, more adult sounding and less of a diminutive. (Although of course it originated as a short form of Elizabeth.)

Eliza or Molly

Voted Lily as its my all time fave, but also think Eliza with Lily as a middle name sounds lovely

My DS would’ve been Eliza if he’d been a girl, so I’d use that.

Eliza. Having two flower names, or 'Rose and Molly' as a sibling duo, sounds twee and matchy-matchy.

Yes I did worry if Rosie and Lily would be too flowery as we definitely don’t want people to think we’d chosen a theme for our children

Molly is quite twee and is cutesy for a child but always feels a bit daft on an adult.

Lily is lovely but used a lot and maybe a bit matchy matchy with Rosie.

I like Eliza.

or Maybe Lila or Lilia if you want something similar to Lily.

How about Lilian

Is Molly a nickname for Mary?

I prefer Eliza and Lily, but I agree that I wouldn’t have a Rosie and Lily.

How about Elise? Beautiful name, imo

I like Eliza best. I think it goes nicely with Rosie and avoids a flower theme.

I love Rosie and Lily together but I'm clearly in the minority!

They’re all nice but Lily is so incredibly popular and is alway tagged with Rose and May.

Personally would avoid Lily. It’s been a very common choice in the last few years.

Damn.
My girls both have Gen stone names. When I think back to secondary school I don’t think anyone in my year particularly paid close attention to my younger sister or her name. And she was two school years younger my girls are three years apart.

I don’t think children in general care much about what others are called… it’s always the parents who judge / form an opinion solely based on the name.

I don’t think my friends parents (from secondary school) knew or cared what my little sisters name was

I prefer Eliza, but especially with Rosie. Two 2 syllable names ending in the ie/y sound is very matchy, especially two floral names together. I like Lily as an individual name, but not with Rosie.

And to add at my child’s school there’s a mother with a daisy and a poppy, if anyone’s judging they’re keeping it to themselves very well. She’s the life and soul of the school gates Amanda from motherland without the bitchiness.
The girls seem happy too.