Help with baby girl names please!

[Beth191]

Here's the shortlist, I don't think we really have a particular style these are just the only names we agree on...middle name will be Joy. We're not sold on any really so any suggestions or opinions welcome :)

Anna
Heidi
Erica
Eliza
Sienna
Erin

Thanks!

Arabella Joy

Heidi or Anna

Really like Eliza.
Heidi is lovely but very popular where I am.

I have a Saffron Niamh and a Sidney Carlotta. Wanted a bit different because ex and I are both teachers, so we tried to avoid any names we’d ever taught.

OP, they’re all nice names, so choose the one you like. Whatever you call her, she will become that name. (All of your options are fine with Joy as a second name - see what they sound like with your surname.)

Love Erin and Erica
Cara
Zara
Saskia
Meredith
Alicia
Elissa/Allissa

Anna is my favourite, followed by Erin and Erica. Not keen on the others, especially Heidi and Sienna.