1st girl.

[IsaidByeByeMissAmericanPie]

Expecting a little girl after two boys.
I like the names...

Nina
Louisa
Orla
Erin
Lyra

Only one my husband agrees on is Orla.

Also like names like Sophia, Aria but ruling them out on popularity... definitely looking for something outside the top 30.

Surname ends in y so don't like the sound of names ending ie or y with it.
Any suggestions?

Elouise is hideous. Eloise is quite nice.

I like Nina best from your list.
How about:

Emma
Zara
Juno
Rosa
Evie
Anna
Grace
Lily
Lucy

All short and sweet

Love Louisa and Erin.
Alicia/Elissa
Zara
Meredith
Esther
Faye
Rosa
Catherine

Carla

Natalia
Nia
Noa
Lila
Lara
Sara

Louella

Lila
romy
mila
edie
alba
cleo
saskia
aurora
leah
willa
cora
quinn
fiadh
maeve
olive

Thanks all. Think we have narrowed it to

Orla
Cora

Middle name possibly Louise.
Cora is the one we both like best that we agree on!

Orla reminds me of oral and Cora reminds me of the popular online forum Quora. I'd go with Nina originally, but now that you've narrowed it down to Cora or Orla, I'd definitely pick Cora. I like Cora.

I vote for Cora - a lovely, short, simple, underused but familiar name

Cora, as in apple corer? Sorry.
Love Cara.

Of the two Orla. In typing it however, i noticed it auto corrects to Orlando 🙁

Does that matter? Lots of names are similar to objects. Orla could be oral etc.

Cara feels way too 1980 for me.