Sister or brother for Emily and Lucy

[Mncrmum]

Hello 👋🏼,

Just found out we're expecting baby number 3. Feels very surreal.

We have an Emily Kate and a Lucy Elizabeth.
Initial thoughts were : Amy Florence (?)

No idea for a boys name 👀

Any suggestions please? I'm hoping talking about names might make this a little more real. ❤️

I know a family with an Emily and a Lucy, the other members of the family are Nicholas and Jessica. All lovely names

Jack or Jessica

Alice
Niall

I have a daughter and a cousin called Emily and Amy. Everyone including me mixes up the names when they're together. There's just something too similar about them.

Mary for very retro?
Isobel for a similar feel and the Izzy shortening?
Elizabeth is lovely with Lizzie for short but maybe you don't want two E names

I don’t mind Amy but I always find it mildly listless, maybe..

Toby
Rory
Barnaby
Zachary
Frederick / Alfred (Freddie)
William (Billy)
Robert (Bobby, Robbie)
Nicholas (Nicky)
Christopher (Christy)

Mary
Nancy
Verity
Chloe
Catherine (Kitty, Katy)
Elizabeth (Lizzy, Libby)
Margaret (Maggie)
Jessica (Jessie)

But I think it might be good to ring the changes

Maybe Florence as a first name or
Catherine
Frances
Beatrice (Bea)
Flora
Clara
Esther
Anna
Philippa (Pippa)

Alistair
Francis (Frank)
Joseph (Joe)
Philip (Pip)
Christopher (Kit)
Samuel
Benjamin
Nathaniel
George

Emily and Amy sound too alike, and Amy is very dated.

Suggestions:
Emily, Lucy, and
Ivy
Phoebe
Romy
Chloe
Sophie
Sylvie
Sadie
Zoe

Thomas
James
William
Frederick
Edmund
Joseph
Daniel
Charles
Benjamin

Emily, Lucy and Anna

Emily, Lucy and Jack

Amy Florence is lovely. I love your children’s names. Lucy would have been our son’s name if he were a girl so I think we might have similar tastes. His name is Matthew and I think Lucy and Matthew sound good together (still hoping to use Lucy one day).

Other names on our list:

Chloe
Hannah
Eve

Isaac
Ethan
Daniel

Naomi
Rachel
Sarah
Zara
Stella
Hazel
Ruth

Ivo
Clement
Ambrose
Myles
Felix
Samuel
Max

My nieces are called Lucy and Emily, their brother is James.

Alice and James

Amy Florence is lovely! Your girls have great names!

We have a Lucy Alexandra, but Lucy Elizabeth was also on our list. We also liked, but couldn't use, Sophie.

Our boys list included
Alexander (Alex) James
James Alexander
David Alexander

I know a family with 3 girls, called Emily, Lucy and Alice

I know of 4 siblings called Lucy, Emily, Sophie and Jack, and another family where the siblings are Lucy, Emily, Anna and Tom.
Also know two Lucys with brothers called Ben.

Sorry meant to say Amy is very nice, maybe a bit too similar to Emily but not ridiculously so... think the twins who played Bethany in coronation street were called Amy and Emily!

I've got sisters called Emily and Lucy though they're both over 40. Other siblings and middle names are Rachel, Rebecca, Sophie (Sophia), Charlotte, Benedict and James. All good classic names!

A few PP have suggested Imogen but that becomes Immie which is v similar to Emily and can be confusing.

First thoughts were Sophie and Henry, both lovely names that go well with your others.

Emily and Lucy are very classic. Amy is ok but a bit less classic. It feels quite dated now whereas the other two are still widely in use. Amy is also a bit samey with Emily.

Emily, Lucy and Charlotte was my initial thought. Thomas or Matthew for boys.

Plenty of classics would go though.

William
George
Henry
Alexander
James
Joseph
Samuel
Daniel

Olivia
Grace
Alice
Isabelle
Jessica
Hannah
Anna
Sophie
Rebecca
Abigail

Emily Kate, Lucy Elizabeth and Amy Florence are a wonderful subset!

Some more suggestions ending in a Y …

Poppy Genevieve
Kayley Adele
Hayley Grace
Sylvie Harriet
Courtney Jade
Felicity Charlotte

Suggestions without Y ending …

Hannah Margaret
Alice Tessa
Olive Lucille
Zara Clare
Isobel Penelope
Juliet Victoria
Nina Roseann
Freya Natalie

Boys suggestions:

Ashley Joseph
Bradley Kurt
Toby Nicholas
Jeremy Daniel
Harry Nathaniel

Benjamin John
Fraser Michael
Thomas Phillip
Wade Derek
Caleb Francis

I have Toby Graham and Joshua James.

Emily, Lucy and Anna
Emily, Lucy and Maria
Emily, Lucy and Jemima
Emily, Lucy and Summer
Emily, Lucy and Catherine
Emily, Lucy and Caroline
Emily, Lucy and Tamsin
Emily, Lucy and Sasha
Emily, Lucy and Saskia
Emily, Lucy and Tabitha

Alice
Kate
Sophie
james
george
Alfie
Arthur

As my name is lucy i will suggest Emily Lucy Martin or Tom

Amy Florence is lovely but I also like Rosie or Sophie with your girls names.

For a boy I think Benjamin, James, Edward or Thomas.

Brian