Baby Girl #3? Philippa, India, and…?

[Juniperjonie]

We have two girls already, Philippa, nn Pippa, and India. Found out baby number three is also a girl! …but not sure on a name yet, want something with a similar feel but can’t decide.

Ideas currently include:
Theodora (nn Dora)
Susanna (nn Susan)
Hallie
Clara
Beatrice
Eleanore (nn Nell/Nellie)
Winifred (nn Winnie? Freddy?)
Josephine (nn Jo)
Ramona
Darcy
Mary
Florence (don’t really like the nn Flo though)
Felicity
Lowena
Peggy
Iona
Shirley
Libby (would probably have to be a nn for Elizabeth though which I’m not sure on..)
Etta (Could this be a nn for Edith?)
Sybil
Helena
Ruth

They’re all kind of all over the place

I wouldn't say Phillipa and India go together as sibling names. To me Phillipa is a serious no nonsense type of name whereas India is a fun modern and whimsical name. Therefore I'd say you can pretty much go in any direction you like. The only thing I'd say is to have another A ending name.
Phillipa India and Sofia. Amelia. Natalia. Martha. Nina. Louisa. Alexia. Alicia. Christina. Vanessa. Maria. Catrina. Sabrina. Samantha. Delilah.Joanna. Amaya. Zara. Julianna. Antonia. Anastasia. Georgina. Teresa. Nicola. Rosanna. Roxanna. Tabitha. Marlena.

You've got a lovely short list to choose from :)

I love-

Clara
Susannah (nn Susie)
Mary
Helena (nn Nell)
Harriet (nn Hattie)

I also like-

Theodora
Felicity
Beatrice
Henrietta (nn Etta)

Celeste or Savannah

I do like the idea of having the third name also end in an a, hadn’t intended that for the first two names, but I agree it will make them go together well with common endings.

Libby can be short for Liberty.