Clara, Anna, Emma, Greta or Nina

[TabMcTat]

Just that really. She will be a younger sister to Arthur and Oscar.

Also bucking the trend and voting for Greta - it’s DD’s name and we love it. We knew when we chose it that it was a marmite name and that some people find it somewhat harsh-sounding, but we didn’t want an obviously ‘pretty’/frilly name and we like its strength, the fact it travels well, and how it’s underused but straightforward to say and spell. No regrets.

It’s a nice list but of the others I think Anna would be my pick - elegant, genuinely classic and again travels well. Emma is fine but a little bland, I can’t warm to the ‘knee’ sound in Nina and Clara is lovely but becoming ubiquitous where I am - it seems to be a bit of a default choice for middle class families looking for an underused classic - to the point that it’s definitely no longer underused (I know five under five)!

I’d go with Clara or Emma.
Anna is lovely too but I think having 2 A initials and 1 O in your sibset would be a bit odd

Greta just gives instant connotations of Greta Thunburg, even without that not a fan at all. Very old lady in a bad way
Don’t like Nina, again quite middle aged vibes.

1. Greta
2. Nina
3. Anna
4. Clara
5. Emma

I can see Greta is a bit of a marmite choice but personally I love it.

Emma - love
Anna - like a lot
Greta - like
Nina - like
Clara- don't like

Which sounds best with the surname?

Greta

Clara and Anna are both lovely classic names. For full disclosure, dd has one of them, and I'd have chosen the other if I'd had another girl!

I like Greta, Nina and Clara the best. I agree with a pp that Anna and Emma sound too vowelly and indistinct with Arthur and Oscar. Tbh I like Clare more, as the ending is more distinct too.

Clara!

Don't like Greta or Clara at all. Other options are great.

Greta or Clara

Anything but Greta and my favourites are Nina and Clara.

Anna and Nina are great names imo.

Other suggestion: Hannah

The kids will obviously separate as they leave home so personally wouldn’t try and make a girl name “fit” the boys. Just a thought.

Greta but a country mile.

Anna as a distant second.

Although I seem to be two decades ahead with name choice so maybe should be ignored.
I have a Raphaela who is 23 and loves her name but have only seen it surface on MN in the past 5 years.
I'm sure if I had asked for feedback in 2000 I would have been shot down.
So if you love a name use it and try not to take MN opinions too seriously.

I would go for Clara. I think it fits best with your sons' names and isn't too old fashioned (I consider Emma and Anna to be a bit 80s and old school sorry!).

Love all of your names except Greta.

Emma, Anna and Clara are 3 of my favourite names.

Nina is a name I’ve recently started liking a lot too

Actually OP I think I’ve changed my mind re both Greta and Anna - having read people's replies I think Greta, while obviously still my favourite, is a bit more of a statement choice, and possibly a bit too edgy and controversial next to Arthur and Oscar, both of which are lovely but very ‘safe’ names. I suspect you’d spend a fair bit of time explaining ‘Why Greta?’ to people. And I agree with pps that Anna sounds too vowelly when put alongside the other two (Emma similar issue but less so I think).

So I think Clara would probably be my revised choice - it’s less vowel-heavy and classic but popular, like your other DCs’ names, so would fit well as a sibset.

Names are a minefield aren’t they?!

My DGD is called Nina, she is 4 now and it's such a cosmopolitan name I think it's lovely.

Nina. It's a lovely name.

I think Emma probably goes best with the boys names but I LOVE the name Nina. Gutted I didn't call one of mine Nina!

Clara
Anna
Like Greta but prefer Gretel

I really dislike Anna.

All the others are lovely though.

Such a lovely list! I adore Nina but I love the others too, including Greta.

May I suggest Edith? Such a great name and goes so well with Arthur and Oscar.

Clara

I like them all but Emma is my favourite