Help with my baby girl name!!

[zzhu]

Hello everyone!
We are expecting our second girl in Feb 2024, we are in Australia so she will be a summer baby. Our first daughter is named Annika.

Rosalie has been on my list since my first pregnancy and I like the NN Rosie. But I am unsure if it's a good match next to Annika.
My husband really likes the name Scarlett.
We also quite like Amelie, it's not too common here, I'm just a bit worried about the confusion with Emily or Amelia.
Would love to hear your opinions on these 3 names! Any other suggestions will be appreciated too.

Annika & Amelie are too matchy in my opinion. Not a fan of Rosalie, feels very trendy at the minute and will age quickly. Rosie is a dog name! Scarlett is gorgeous, I’ve always loved it

Annika is lovely

I agree with PP Amelie is too matchy. I quite like Scarlet but it’s been a bit overdone here (don’t know about Australia?). Rosalie is a bit twee and a bit gypsy Rose lee for me - how about Rosanna / Rosanagh? but there are a lot of Rosies around

Verity
Meredith
Lois
Inez
Carina
Carys
Lara
Freya
Ffion
Seren
Yolanda
Jocelyn
Vivienne
Zara
Sabrina
Maria
Philippa (Pippa)
Victoria (Vita)

All lovely names. Scarlett would be my pick.

Annika and Scarlett go very well.
Amelie is sweet but too matchie. Rosalie is okay.
Ideas ..
Scarlett Matilda
Matilda Alice
Victoria Scarlett
Cecilia May (after author of Snugglepot and Cuddlepie.)
Skye Indigo

Rosalie is so much better then Scarlett.

Annika is lovely! I prefer Rosalie from your choices. Amelie is OK but sounds quite similar. Personally, I dislike Scarlett.

Rosalie - not keen, just Rosa or Rosie is nicer. I like Rosanna but it doesn't go with Annika. Rosalind is nice
Scarlett - like
Amelie - looks pretty but Emily sounds much nicer

Scarlett Anything might sound like a description

I'm not a fan of Scarlett and prefer Rosalind to Rosalie

Rosalie is the nicest. Amelie doesn't really go with Annika.
What about Kirrily? That would go well with Annika.

Scarlet is my least favourite of the names, to me it's a colour not a name somehow.
Amelie is nice, very popular in the UK.
Other ideas
Natalie or Nathalia
Lucy or lucinda
Bethany
Theodora
Nivea
Henrietta/ Ettie or hattie for short
Claudia

Not that keen on any of your names, sorry. Rosalie is the best, and I do think it works with Annika, but it's getting very overdone, at least in the UK. Amelie I find quite tired now. And Scarlett jiust isn't nice IMO.

Annika's vaguely Nordic (she's a character in Pippi Longstocking, anyway) so I might go for something else in that style - Astrid, Linnea? Other names I think go well with Annika, without being too similar/matchy, are Natasha, Erin, Beatrice, Sadie, Lucia, Elizabeth.

I love Amelie.
I don't think it would be a problem with confusing it for Emily or Amelia.

Rosalie is pretty too, and goes well with your other daughter's name.

@finalspincycle , Amelie and Emily, and Amelia and Emilia, are often confused.

I'm going to say Scarlett because I have one. It's not overused (well it isn't here) but is a well known name. She's the only one in her school (in fact she's been to 3 schools and has been the only Scarlett) and I like that. Amelie would be my 2nd pick

I love Rosalie, it’s certainly not overused where I live. Scarlett I’m less keen on but I do think it goes quite well with Annika. Not really a fan of Amelie.

I really like Annika with Scarlett.
Annika and Rosalie is ok.
I don't like Annika and Amelie. Too matchy and I think Amelie sounds a bit mushy and soft next to Annika. Whereas Annika and Scarlett are both quite hard sounding (which I like).

How about
Ingrid
Felicity
Charlotte
Diane
Hazel
Janet
Nadine
Josephine
Roxanne

I like Rosalie with Annika

Amelia and Emilia are the Spanish version of Amelie and Emily. Same names just different language...

Our little girl is Amélie (love this name) but many people call her Emily or Amelia at first. Even my mum!

Rosalie is lovely.

I think Freya goes well with Annika

I think Rosalie is great.