Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

My Sister-in-law named baby daughter after my Husbands ex-girlfriend

41 replies

Outsiderinsider · 31/08/2023 09:18

When I met my husband he had very recently split up with his ex. They had been together 5 years and his family adored her and she became close with my husbands sisters.
His ex girlfriend broke contact with the family as she found it painful, especially when he met me, and over time his family became friendlier towards me.
When I became pregnant we were thrilled and my husbands family appeared to be happy too, at the same time my husbands sister also became pregnant, and was due a bit before me.
A few weeks before our due dates we all attended a family party.My husbands ex was there with her new boyfriend. I’d like to add at the point my husbands ex-girlfriend is adorable and very respectful to me and my husband.
At the event the ex congratulated my mother-in-law on her up coming grandchildren, and my MIL was overhead (and later confirmed) saying “what can I say(about the baby)" and then “we like her but still love you” she was also heard making derogatory comments about me.
This was the first I knew my mil was unhappy about our baby, because she pretended to be as excited as we were. I didn’t let on I knew anything, but I was humiliated and devastated.

Two weeks after the wedding my sister in law gave birth to a baby girl, and called her the same name as the ex girlfriend. Going through the process myself I know how contentious the name choosing process is, and was shocked….people around us, including me, assumed the baby was named after the ex. Apparently it was just a name my sister-in-law loved. But it was embarrassing for me.
I have since also had a baby daughter, (given a unique name), and she is very much loved by the family, even if I am a clear outsider.... I have tried desperately to move on, but over time I have become more upset, angry and bitter.
Recently all the men in the family went out together and then (apparently spontaneously) the woman also got together, but my daughter and I wasn’t included… when I voiced my sadness, I was turned against with every excuse why they didn't include us.
It is clear they don’t like me, and I’m grown up enough to know this. And I’m happy to step away and let my DH and daughter have a relationship with his family without me. But I’m being told it’s in my head and that I’m imagining things. I’m now being made to feel unreasonable because I have pulled away from the family. But I feel much happier keeping away.
My husband is a very non confrontational person, so has never said anything much to defend me and his family would twist it all anyway. They always do.
I really would just like to know other peoples opinions. Should I move on? Am I being sensitive?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
BanditsOnTheHorizon · 31/08/2023 11:31

The name wouldn't bother me, especially as it's a common name.

But MIL slagging me off would be an issue. I'd step right back and not bother attending family events or getting involved. Let your DH know what she said and why you no longer want a relationship with them. As for your dd, your dh can facilitate relationship with them

harriethoyle · 31/08/2023 11:43

They sound really horrid OP - particularly "I like her but love you". I would definitely go LC with them, and restrict myself to a couple of occasions a year. Also think your DH needs to grow a backbone too...

ittakes2 · 31/08/2023 12:07

I don't feel close to my hubby's family although I have tried - and he recognises my efforts and has my back. If he ever feels I am not being treated 100% he will not only say but would refuse to participate without me - his family might not love me but they show me respect. I wish that for you too.

peaceinourtime · 31/08/2023 21:12

Move on

MrsDrDear · 31/08/2023 21:54

But I feel much happier keeping away

Then keep your distance. Life's too short to spend it with people who make you miserable or doubt yourself.

user1492757084 · 01/09/2023 12:26

Do what makes you happy however don't leave your husband to go to family events alone.
Go and have a nice time with him and your daughter.
The old ones will die off and the sisters are friends with the ex but she is nice (you say).
Life is too short to think about some things.

Hanasmother · 01/09/2023 15:34

In this case, you have full rights! There is No problem with you. You have the rights to be invited to family gatherings, but if they are low-minded people, don't hesitate and talk about it with you husband! Find out what's going on his mind?? Is he ok with their bitching around? If so... You should think of a solution to help your life!

TakeMe2Insanity · 01/09/2023 15:43

I would choose to be unavailable to them. Family dinner, ah we have plans, christmas well you guys are with your family/ just as a family etc. Yes you are missing out on a family but you aren’t you are missing out on their negativity. If they are trying to gaslight you and say it’s in your head it’s better just to walk away. Your DH doesn’t sound as if he is standing up for you, so in this instance I’d control the family diary - something with in laws comes up oh we’ve got tickets etc.

They really should have either moved on from ex or just loved her as a family friend but never accepting you because they wanted her was never going end well.

Liv999 · 01/09/2023 19:41

OP I don't think you're being sensitive about the baby name thing at all, I mean out of the millions of names out there they had to choose your husbands ex name, even if it is a top 10 name, pull the other one...and then to have people wondering if the baby was named after her, I'd be extremely upset too

Hibiscrubbed · 01/09/2023 20:34

my MIL was overhead (and later confirmed) saying “what can I say(about the baby)" and then “we like her but still love you” she was also heard making derogatory comments about me.

This is really horrible. Really. As is then excluding just you from a family get-together.

Your husband is failing you massively by allowing them to treat you this way.

I’d stop trying entirely and would make precisely no effort for any of them again. They don’t like you, they prefer her, trying harder won’t change that. So stop.

MILofdoom · 01/09/2023 22:32

I agree with PP with regards to let your DH deal with that side of the family fully.

My DH is spineless too with this shit too and that probably infuriates me more than what his mother does/says.

I don't entertain it at all now, if he forgets it's her birthday, to get Mother's Day gifts etc not my bloody problem and I'd be angry if he added my name to anything with how she's behaved. I do envy people with lovely in-laws.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 01/09/2023 23:04

Really feel for you but your mil sounds like a shit stirring bag. Also am I right 3 daughters so really difficult situation. If it was 3 sons would be easier. Just get on with your life and try not to let them live in your head rent free. Horrible when you sense and know people talk about you behind your back and are two faced. Have been in same situation and take a step back as cannot be fake either, they seemed to talk about everyone and anyone and then if they were with those same people all nice and fake. Find something else to fill your time and do not let them cause a wedge between you and your little family. Say nothing about them at all which is the best thing and only go to occasions where you really have to and be all happy and smiley as that will piss them off. Probably jealous of you as that is usually the cause. Do you have your own family near you by any chance. It is their ignorance and nasty nature so let them off with it.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 01/09/2023 23:05

As for the name thing seems weird and bet mil was loving that. Feck them all and try to live your best life.

Outsiderinsider · 02/09/2023 08:29

Outsiderinsider · 31/08/2023 11:27

Like I said it might have just been me :) I just wouldn't have picked the name if the situation was reversed, especially given the thousands of names there are to pick. It was very weird at the time and widely discussed amongst our friends, hence why I was embarrassed.... I have found it difficult to move on... clearly :(

i have literally just seen an article on baby names, and it’s not actually in the top 10… or even the top 40. Not that it matters 🤣
I definitely need to just focus on me/us now.
it’s been great hearing everyone’s views.

OP posts:
Parlourgames · 02/09/2023 08:37

I’m very sorry for your feelings of being an outsider and hurt.

However, if you cut yourself off then you will be even more of an outsider and never get closer to your husband’s family. Can you try and feel neutral and bland about them? Where possible try not to feel hurt by them. As time passes it may all change. I’ve seen this in other marriages and sometimes at the end of a long life people can be grateful to have in their lives the people they found difficult when they were younger.

Samzzz · 03/09/2023 08:32

Your DH needs to tell them it’s unacceptable and until they apologise and take accountability your daughter is going nowhere without you!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page