Which name from our shortlist?

[Cuggl]

Our baby boy is already here and we are still struggling... thought we would be able to make an easy decision after his arrival.

1. Elliot
2. Noah
3. Theodore
4. Oliver

Sister is Grace.

Thank you!

Elliot

Hate Theo.

Deffo Elliott

Lots of Noahs and Olivers around my neck of the woods, only one Theodore and no Elliots. I love Theodore personally as can be Ted Teddy Ned Theo as appropriate

Theodore

I know someone with an Oliver and a Grace and think they go well together, but Oliver is quite popular at the moment. I've always loved the name Elliot.

Elliot or Oliver.

Theo in preference to Theodore.

Not Noah, such a whiny name.

How about Oscar Op?

Elliot

I like them all but Elliot is my favourite.

Theodore is my favourite

noah goes best with grace

Theo or Oliver

Elliot

Oliver.
Congratulations on your new baby son xx

Grace and Noah

Elliot

Elliot is probably the most unusual at the moment and my favourite from the list. Noah is nice and Theodore nn Theo is ok.
Oliver is really overused just now, at least where I live.

Elliot can be spelt in different ways so he might get Elliott or Eliot, and El names are very popular especially for girls.

I think Theo/Theodore/Teddy outnumber Noah and Oliver by a considerable amount if you combine their popularity.

The ONS baby names page shows popularity by region. Not many Elliots here.

Theodore nn Theo/Teddy

Links: Baby names in England and Wales - Office for National Statistics (ons.gov.uk)
Baby names in England & Wales since 1996 (darkgreener.com)

I think the Elliots I know are one each of Elliot, Elliott and Eliot. They are adults.
Oliver might be easier regarding spelling. The Graces and Olivers I know are adults.

The Noahs and Theos I know are children so the names seem more faddy.