Heidi, Harriet, Rosa or Polly

[GreenAventurine]

Which is your most and least favourite? - Heidi, Harriet, Rosa or Polly…

Herriot
Heidi
Polly
Rosa

In that order.

Heidi. Absolutely love this.
Then Rosa. Then Harriet.
Not keen on Polly at all.

Rosa definitely

Polly
Harriet
Rosa

Dislike Heidi

All four names are sweet.
It depends on the second name/family name and the surname as to whether I like one more than the other.

Polly - casual, uncommon but well known and Mary related.
Heidi - European, familiar but not over popular, vibrant.
Harriet - traditional, cute nick names, womanly.
Rosa - beautiful, under used, Italian flavour, simple.

Polly is lovely.
Heidi awful.
Like Hattie but not Harriet.
Rosa is nice .

Love your list, we must have very similar taste as we considered all of these.
Unfortunately for us Harriet and Rosa were out as we have these (or very close variations) already in the family. I think Harriet is classic and beautiful, with good nickname options. Don’t come across it often and all the Harriets I know are lovely.
I really liked Polly, DH vetoed it due to it being a bit cutesy with the nursery rhyme associations, although I don’t get this vibe from the name. Heidi is still in consideration for us.
I’m surprised to see some people loving Heidi and disliking Polly, or vice versa, as to me they have very similar vibes - although obviously opinion differs!
Honestly don’t think you can go wrong with any from your list, all lovely names.

Heidi, Harriet and Polly were on my list 17 years ago but I had boys!

Rosa
Heidi
Harriet

Polly, lol no

harriet -love, especially shortened to Hattie
Heidi - really nice
Rosa - it’s ok, perfectly decent name
Polly - not keen

Harriet 1st
Polly 2nd

Don't like the other two

I most like Rosa. Least like Heidi.

A mix then! 😄

Oh no, I think you’ve ruined Heidi for me!!

Love Rosa.
Not keen on Harriet . Like Hattie.
Really dislike Heidi & Polly

I really like all of them so it is hard to choose but I am going with - Harriet, Polly, Rosa, Heidi. Heidi definitely last (although I like it) but the others could be in any order really!

I like them all, but I think Harriet and Rosa have the slight edge over Heidi and Polly. There's not a lot in it though!

Harriet only one I like.
Heidi
Polly
Rosa.

Heidi is my absolute favourite, love that name. Then Rosa which is really pretty as well, lovely name. And then Harriet which I'm not as keen on and then Polly which I dislike.

Heidi, Harriet, Polly, Rosa - in that order.

Harriett is my favourite. Rosa is my least favourite if you live in the uk as I don't like the pronunciation here

Polly. Such a sweet choice and not popular.

Rosa is my favourite, followed by Harriet.

Heidi is okay.

Dislike Polly. I think it is a very twee name.

Rosa, Polly, Harriet then Heidi.

I don't see Heidi as being in the same bracket as the first three somehow, I don't know why. For me, it's the equivalent of something that goes well only some of the time, instead of all of the time. That's just me though. It's still pretty. Similarly Harriet but less so, but I think Rosa and Polly are lovely all-round names and not that common either.

Rosa is lovely
Never been keen on Harriet