Which of these two names would you choose?

[Shoequeen1]

Jack or Frank? Frank would possibly have nickname Frankie

Jack is so so common. Wasn't it THE top boys names for years recently? There must be tens of thousands Jacks out there already.

Frank is more memorable!

@pinkpanther84 Good choice!!

Jack

@Lavenderblues Yes I think it was in the top names, I don't know any children of either name in real life.

I have a great niece called Frankie.
I like Jack

Jack. Classic but sounds fresh and modern at the same time. Frank I don't like...prefer Frankie but think it will date.

I know 3 toddlers called Jack. No Frankies at all.

Jack!

Frank isnt to my taste at all and I personally prefer Frankie for a girl even though all the Frankie's I know are boys!

And now I've typed frankie too many times and it doesnt feel like a word anymore haha

Jack, though maybe more keen on Jackson becuase all the teachers tend to be extra wary of the Jacks

Jack
Frankie at least where I live in way more common amongst younger children

Both cute names. I know a few little Franks, and have taught a load of Jacks who must now all be young men, but I don’t know any little Jacks so I don’t think it is as popular/common as it once was.

Similar names to me are Sam, Fred, Stan.

Jack. (Round here a Jackson would be naughty...)

Frank is dated for me and Frankie short for Francesca.

I much prefer Jack. I am not keen on Frank and really dislike Frankie

Of the two, Jack - but I wouldn't choose either myself. Surely you can try again and find something you both like?!

Nate?

I know a Frank (young teenager) - really suits him! Jack just does nothing for me at all.

Frank

I'm not too keen on Frank and helpmum2003 hit the nail on the head with the whole Francessca thing, I also think jack (or jackson) would only be fine with a interesting surname, because Jack Smith or Jack White doesnt really do it for me ...

@IncrediblySadToo I like both to be honest, but I am more drawn to Jack than Frank. My husband likes both but prefers Frank! Naming babies is hard work!!

@bertiebottseveryfalvourbeans That is funny!!! Something that would never even enter my head to think of!!

I have a 25 year old Frank, when he was little he was Frankie but it just morphed into Frank as he grew up. He is Francis on his birth cert though, just in case he gets made a peer or becomes a very sensible something!

Hmmm it's tough. They're both popular where we are (Frankie more so than just Frank) we know a girl Frankie, and 2 boy Frankie's, 2 Jacks and a Jackson! Also know a Franklin, which I think is nicest for a boy.

Definitely Jack.

Frank is more unusual

Definitely Jack!