Elsie Rose or Emmie Rose

[BettyBoo246]

(Has to be Rose middle name as chosen by our ds)

I love Elsie !!

Don't make me broody 

I really dislike both sorry. Emmy is wet and sickly and Elsie is just awful. Elsie Tanner.

My DD's middle name is Rose (3 months) I actually hate popular names, which is why her first name is a lot more uncommon but Rose is just so beautiful it made me not care.

I would sway towards Emmie BUT I think she may often be asked if it's Emma.

Elsie ? Why is this name popular?. It makes me think of Elsie Tanner. Sorry but I think it's a really ugly name.

I prefer Emmy spelt with a Y. Elsie is boring and overused. The actress who plays Fiona on the US Shameless is named Emmy Rossum.

Emmy or Emmie is nice as a shortening for something else - Emila, Emmeline, Emma, Emily, Emmanuelle. I think putting a longer name on the birth certificate gives her flexibility when she's older - I use mine professionally but friends/family/school knew and know me by the short version.

Elsie I don't dislike but my first thought is Edwardian scullery maid.

Emmi Rose