Which of these names do you like the best?

[inajam]

For a girl, the middle name would be Elizabeth or Olive (whichever suits the first name best) and for a boy, the middle name would be John. Let me know your thoughts!

Girls

Esther
Martha
Alexandra
Edith
Charlotte
Alice
Grace
Beatrice
Eloise
Tabitha

Boys

Edward
Gregory
Louis
Benjamin
Arthur
Rupert

I like Martha elizabeth and Rupert John

Alexandra Elizabeth (planning Alexandra or Alexandria ourselves)
Rupert John (love love love Rupert but dh wasn’t keen but thankfully we’ve got a girl this time so not an argument I had to have)

Grace and Arthur

Eloise Olive (love this) and Gregory John

In order, I like:
Edith Elizabeth
Charlotte Elizabeth
Martha Elizabeth
Tabitha Elizabeth
Alice Elizabeth
Beatrice Olive
Esther Elizabeth
Alexandra Elizabeth
Grace Elizabeth

I don't like Eloise at all.

Boys
Gregory
Benjamin
Arthur
Edward
Rupert
Louis

Tabitha and Rupert.

Tabitha and Rupert

Alice & Alexandra

Edward & Benjamin

Eloise and Rupert

Esther Elizabeth is beautiful.

Esther Elizabeth
Alice Elizabeth

Edward John
Arthur John

I really like almost all of your choices except Grace and Gregory.

Esther Elizabeth and Gregory John

Alexandra and Gregory

Martha Elizabeth
Charlotte Elizabeth
Grace Elizabeth

Edward John

Alice and Edward.
Prefer Elizabeth to Evelyn.

Alice Elizabeth and Greogory John. Great list.

Esther Olive and Gregory John

I’m so pleased to hear people liking Gregory! That’s the main one DH is a bit unsure of but is my favourite (sorry Dolly!)

It is going to be very hard to pick just one, but it seems Elizabeth is the most popular middle name choice.

Edith Elizabeth
Beatrice Elizabeth
Edward John
Arthur John

I love Esther, It's due a comeback I reckon!

Esther Elizabeth and Edward John

Esther, Tabitha or Martha

Edward or Louis

So adding up the numbers, Martha and Edward are top runners, with Esther, Arthur and Gregory close behind. (Ive taken Benjamin off the list today because I’ve realised I didn’t love it as much when people were saying yes to that one, and also his initials... )
My personal favourite for a girl is Edith so I’ve kept that on the list too

I think Alice Elizabeth is such a beautiful name, as is Grace Elizabeth.

I also like Gregory John and Louis John. On its own I love the name Benjamin but I don't think it matches with John as well, not that it matter much

Not keen on the middle name Olive, you'd have to go for a more unusual first name for it to match

Louis John.
Alexandra Olive.

I like the following:

Esther
Alexandra
Alice
Beatrice

Edward
Gregory
Arthur
Rupert

My favourites are Beatrice and Rupert.