Down to three...

[deptfordgirl]

Not certain yet but currently these are our top 3. We already have one ds who has a biblical name outside the top 100.

Edward, Caleb, Luke.
I think Caleb goes the best with ds's name but I love Edward. Luke is nice but our surname is 1 syllable. Not sure about Lucas/Luca.

Matilda, Tabitha, Harriet.
Like these equally!

Love Edward and Tabitha.

Lots of love for Edward.

We've got a close family member who has just had a Freddie. Would Edward inevitably get Eddie and is this weird? What else could he be?

My favourites from your lists are Edward and Harriet :-)

Caleb, and any of your girls names, they're all lovely !

Edward

Tabitha

Edward and Harriet!
I like Luke and Matilda second.

Love your name choices. You could always choose a multi syllable name for a middle name if you went with Luke.

Caleb and Tabitha are a bit more out there than the other choices. Matilda has been very popular in recent years so a bit of its time

Edward is a great choice and has many nn options eg Ed, Ned, Ted(dy)

I have a three month old Edward, who currently goes by Ted :) We love his name and most people are very complimentary.

Harriet was one of my favourite options for a girl too, so you obviously have impeccable taste