Can I have an Annie, Oliver and Matilda?

[Slocky]

Is it too much...?

As long as the hills are alive with the sound of music

Love it! :)

Are you planning on more children? You could have Tommy, Evita, Bugsy Malone, Mary Poppins, Les Miserables, Frozen, Chicago, Mamma Mia ...

I think it's fine

Totally fine. It's not a bad connection and not that obvious anyway - all are very well-known names, it's not like they only have one association! All lovely names btw

P.s. All classic names that existed well before medieval times and musicals...

I clicked on the thread wondering why on earth it wouldn't be okay. Hadn't occurred to me at all.

#uncultured

Heh - maybe if you didn't get Carmen, Mimi and Giovanni... Or Juliette, Romeo and Othello. I think not recognising musicals might make you super-cultured?

No!
I thought you were joking. But you're serious.

DD1 was supposed to be Annie but thank god we changed at the last minute because she is now a curly redhead!

Lovely names, go for it!

It's fine! They're individuals and will be for the rest of their lives. I've never quite got why 'working' with siblings names matters so much.

It's too much IMO.

I think you can, they're all lovely names and I wouldn't immediately make the connection. And as you've got two out of the three already, you might as well go for it!
Would Oliver and Matilda ever be Ollie and Tilly as that would lessen the musicals effect?

I love the names, definitely can!

I would add Charlie & Billy too.

My DS loves the fact that he is actually Alexander as he's a bit obsessed with another certain musical (waves to Hercules Mulligan)

I think it's fine if you want to be the sort of family who embrace it!

If not then don't!

I love theatre but I wouldn't want to be the 'novelty' family so I wouldn't.