Scottish sibling name for Logan?

[Popskipiekin]

We are expecting our second boy and already have a Logan. We would love another Scottish name. Our surname is two syllables, ending -ie. So far DH and I like Finlay - he would be known as Finn - and are arguing about Cameron which I don't like as it makes me think of David Cameron but I know that's silly .
What do you think about Dougal (spelt any number of ways)? and any other ideas? A very good friend's boy is Douglas so I feel I can't use it although I do like it.
Thank you!

How about Hamish? I love that one!

Dougal doesn't do it for me, but Doug is a nice nn. I do like Finlay (and Finn) though!

Murray?

Callum, Atholl, Blair, Duncan?

I don't like Cameron (for the same reason as you!) and I don't like Dougal because of the Magic Roundabout.
I like Finlay although it is very popular. In our immediate friendship circle there are two.
I also like Torquil; Callum and Kyle.

Gregor, Craig, Euan, Jamie?

Lachlan? Lindsay?

Ruairidh?

Dougie (as in doogie not duggie) I like, Brodie, Callum, Drew, Eoin, Mac (a bit out there granted), Grant, Lachlan, Lewis, Murray, Struan.

Angus, Struan, Fraser, Donald, Andrew, Alistair, Bruce, Malcolm.

I like Rory, or Brodie.

Archie

Thank you for all the great suggestions! I should have mentioned in OP that we have long-running family middle name of James which DS2 will get so Hamish is out, though I agree it's great.
I am starting to realise that Finlay is popular... DS1 is not yet 2 so we aren't mixing with masses and masses of children.
Is the magic roundabout still going? won't it just be people of a certain generation who will make that connection?
Torquil - wow that's a bit left-field (for me) but starting to kind of grow on me!
Lots of the same names coming up - will take the thread to DH and discuss

The only Logan I know has a brother named Fergus

I'm expecting #2 and in Scotland. My potentials are Brodie, Callum and Robin.

I'm expecting #2 and in Scotland. My potentials are Brodie, Callum and Robin.

Lorne (might be too similar)
Struan
Finlay
Callum
Ruairaidh
Lewis

Yy only old people like me will make the Magic Roundabout connection and then only a tiny percentage would think it was a bad thing!

I like Brodie but it's also very popular where we are - there are two in my niece's class.

Alasdair?

Brodie sadly way too similar to our surname but I love it. Callum would go really well. I think Atholl is fab but DH not remotely keen. Maybe I can work on him :)
Alasdair is a lovely name I hadn't actually considered. I see there's at least one thread on MN about the spelling of it so will look into that side.
All other great ideas - maybe there's just too many brilliant Scottish names and that's our problem!
APlaceOnTheCouch haha DH & I weren't around when it aired but we've still heard of it - presumably passed on from our parents - and it is the First thing they said when we tentatively aired Dougal (for DS1). As you say, really not a bad thing - it's a sweet connection really.

Dougal/Dougie is too well-known to be linked only with The Magic Roundabout. (That's not a bad thing in my opinion, anyway.) I know more than one Dougal, and all are really nice chaps. There was also Dougal Haston, the famous, charismatic and controversial mountaineer...

I like Torquil. As I'm sure you know, it's Viking-Scottish; a version of the Norse Thorkill.

Several other good names have been mentioned already. There's also Innes, Donal (English version - Gaelic available), Duncan (ditto), Magnus ...

Harris?

Andrew, Keir, Kerr, Skene, Gavin, Thane, Lachlan.

Haven't rtft, but how about Lachlan or Finlay.

I really like Dougal, and the Magic Roundabout is a plus not a minus IMO

I like Torin, bit different but easy to pronounce.