Out of these two, which one?

[user1465744104]

I'm so undecided I prefer Elliot, but Isaac goes better with DS1's name. DH prefers Isaac...

So, Elliot or Isaac?

Isaac.

Elliott! The fact it's part of my username shows my liking for this name!
I know two little Elliotts and they are both lovely!

Elliot. I know of 4 Isaac's under the age of 4, it's very popular

Isaac

Isaac by a long way . It is one of my favourite boy names, has a lovely meaning and I just don't like Elliott at all (sorry).

Isaac.

Isaac!

Elliot wins my vote.

Definitely Elliot!

Elliot

I have an Isaac and never has there been someone who has lived the meaning of their name to such an extent. He is a true delight! I would recommend using the name on the off chance that it has a magic power and turns all children into charming, funny bundles of joy!

Elliott. Isaac and noah together are too biblical.

Isaac

I have a Noah and an Elliot!

Isaac is nice too, but I obviously think that Elliot is nicer.

Isaac is a great name.

Isaac for me but both are lovely names.
Congratulations!

On it's own it would be Issac for me but I think Elliot goes better with Noah unless you want to be v religious

I prefer Elliot unless you are particularly religious. Isaac is a nice name but combined with Noah too biblical for my tastes

Isaac by a very long way!

And congratulations!!

Isaac. Elliot reminds me of Fred Elliot from corrie

Elliot.

Definitely Isaac. Elliot is not anywhere near as nice

I have an Isaac.

He is 13, it was very uncommon when we named him, but I hear a lot of smaller Isaac's so I think it is getting more common.

It is a great name, good on child or adult, nice meaning, classic but not boring etc.

personally I really dislike the name Elliot, but can't really say why.

What about using both? Isaac, and Elliot as a middle name.

I would go for Isaac. He could then be Zach for short... or you could call him Zachary. No wait. ISAAC. Just stick with Isaac. Although I do like Zach a lot...

I don't know about Elliot. I guess because there are so many girls names starting with Elle/Ella/Ellie.. so it seems a little feminine. Isaac is strong and classical.