Help with boys names....

[BumpPower]

Be gentle, not braved the baby names page yet but DS2 is officially cooked and ready anyway and we still don't really have any boys names.....so need some wise mnetters ideas.
We only could agree on one last time - Edward - but I hear it's frowned upon to give your DCs the same name...!
Main criteria is fairly mainstream but not in the top 20, ideally the only one in his class/year (I have a v popular name for.my age and was always bump1 or one the bumps at school.). I'm a teacher so have a million unreasonable reasons for vetoing perfectly good names!

Names I like but DP doesn't:
Benedict/Ben
Rory
Fredrick (fair enough can't have Freddie and Teddy)

Names he likes but I don't:
Roger
Peter
Philip

Can you help?

I love Roger, there's practically no chance of another Roger in a class

Toby
Jared
Tristan
Spencer

Adam, Dominic, Evan, Marcus, Lawrence, Christopher, Andrew, Isaac, Zachary.

I just think of.... the cabin boy as soon as I hear Roger...wrong I know bit still....

Evan is nice - not too Welsh? (nothing against Welsh names just feel we have no claim to it....)

we have an Edward who's a Teddy, and i love Frederick.... but DH thinks Freddy and Teddy is a no - is it?!

I love alexander, but my best mate just used it (boo)

Other names on our list (if it helps as we seem to have same taste!)

Barnaby (Barney)
Albert (Bertie)
Callum
Jacob
Elliott
Spencer
Daniel

I love a lot of scottish names but DH doesn't like then

Angus
Hamish
Fergus
Fraser
Innes
Douglas

Names DH likes but i don't
Austin
James
Timothy.

Not heard of innes is that pronounced how it looks ins?
The father in law is Scottish (and called William Wallace for added Scottishness) and v keen on Scottish names. Angus might be too far but Hamish is lovely...although I once had a dog called Hamish.
Why is this so hard?

Rueben

There was a scottish family over the road from us their boys were called Fergus, Archie and Innes - prounounced "in-ess".

Yes i had a hamster called hamish ha ha - still rather like it though!

Ooooo Rueben - will raise that one after dinner!

I really don't like any of your DP's name choices if that helps

Julian (nn Jude)
Arthur
Sebastian
Nathaniel
Nicholas

If you like Reuben, how about Rufus?

If you like Scottish names how about:

Keir
Hector
Angus
Fraser
Lachlan
Ian
Stuart
Andrew
Ivo
Alasdair

Or otherwise how about Elliot, Patrick or Lawrence

Duncan was my Scottish name choice but wasn't allowed it

Please don't spell it Rueben.

Agree correct spelling Reuben it's on my list!

Gregor or Gregory
Patrick
Miles

Ooooo miles is nice!

DP has suggested Robert.... Scottish but not overly so.... Bobby as a knickname (obv accepting that when he's old enough he'd drop it from Rob).... I Don't hate it.
Only horrid Rob I know is on the Archers....

Robert is a great choice (my brother's name).

Another great name that goes well with Edward, and is Scottish but not overly so, is Alexander. Teddy and Alex, or Teddy and Zander, or Teddy and Lexy are all good combos too.

Conrad
Alfred
Anthony
Aidan
Glenn
Craig
Blair
Bryce

Samuel
Callum