Florence, Eleanor, Madeline, Darcey or Imogen?

[shalalala]

Help! Any thoughts on the above? (Florence, Madeline, Darcey, Imogen, Amelia) Surname beginning with H. Middle name may be Elizabeth x

Darcey (Darcy was on our list if DS was a girl!)

I like Madeline best. And Eleanor.

Eleanor, but then I'm biased it's DD1s name

Madeline.

They are all lovely except Darcey. Where I live it seems to be a faddy name which everyone is using.

I think it does depend on your area... I have yet to meet a Darcy/Darcey!

Darcey is a very different style to the other names on your list. It's a trendy name, whereas your others are classic.

Florence, Madeline and Imogen go well with Elizabeth for a middle name, Eleanor & Amelia less so IMO.

Also, the spelling Madeleine would be more usual if you don't want to have to correct people. I prefer Madeline, though.

Florence or Madeline

Not Darcy! The rest are lovely.

Madeleine is my favourite.
Then Eleanor as its so classic.

Not darcey. It's less chic

Madeleine! I love this name. So beautiful. I'd spell it with the extra e though. I think it is more recognised.
Second would be Imogen. Then Eleanor - I really like Eleanor but the popularity of the inevitable Ellie does put me off.
I find Florence and Amelia a bit boring.
All of the above are far, far nicer than Darcey IMO.

Eleanor, it's lovely.

I'm glad everyone agrees with me wrt Darcey I'd choose a short name to precede a long middle name, if that is helpful.

I really dislike Madeleine and am not overly fond of Darcey. Like your other choices

I don't think Darcey fits I agree. It is a fashion name, will date and isn't a classic.

The rest are all nice, I prefer Florence I think.

I like them all except Darcey. Florence is my favourite.

Another vote for Eleanor. I too like all the names except Darcey.x

I like Eleanor but not Ellie/ Ella( which is also very popular these days.) I would like Madeleine next best, with the extra e. Florence also lovely. The others appeal to me less. Agree with others that Darcey is a different sort of name and might not have the classic staying power of the rest.

I like them all except Florence but if had to choose it would be Eleanor (but not Ellie).

Four classics...and Darc(e)y.

I love Imogen.

My preferred order would be exactly as ashesandfires says

Know 3 under 2 year old Darcey's (London).

Imogen grates, just sounds wannabe pretentious and twee.

Like Florence, Madeleine & Amelia the best.

Thanks everyone. Think 2 E's (Eleanor Elizabeth) is ok?