Girls names list thoughts?

[Beccabooboo]

I am expecting my second girl and struggling with names
I have a Scarlett who also has 2 other Scarletts in her class. Looking to avoid this but not too out there either
This is what I have so far ;

Gretel
Winnie
Edie
Jemima
Hettie

Thoughts?

I like Edie and Jemima.

Really dislike Gretel

Like Winnie!

How about Claudia/Enid/Heidi/Daphne?

I like Jemima, and Gretel is ok, although I prefer Greta. Winnie, Edie and Hettie I prefer short for Winifred, Edith and Henrietta.

I like Jemima! Not sure about Gretel...

There's a few Edies in dd's school so I might avoid that. Love Hettie - short for Harriet? Winnie is awful, as is Gretel.

The one in the middle, Edie.

Gretel and Winnie are seriously bad.

I love Jemima

Quite like Edie (though I'd christen Edith) and Gretel

Don't like Winnie or Hettie at all.

Good list.

Jemima wins for me. Quite a timeless name.

Also like Hettie if short for Henrietta or Esther

Edit best. Winnie awful. Rest OK.

Gretel is nice but feels like a little girl name.

Thanks guys. I think I am more confused than ever. My haves were Gretel and Winnie but I realise these are are seriously marmite! Only know if one Edie around here but am guessing will gain more popularity. Think I am leaning towards Jemima.

Yes rueset, I think of the cute little Gretel in the sound of music! Maybe not so much when she is older.

Love Gretel such a beautiful name

Edie or Jemima

I really like Jemima.

Gretel was traditionally a diminutive of Grete, which was a short form of Margaret. As Reuset says, it's traditionally cute and little girly - rather like Rosie compared with the plainer, more adult, Rose.

I know of more than one little Edie. For that, and for Winnie and Hettie, I prefer full names, rather than rather babyish short forms.

Winnie. what about Hattie?

Totally agree with Sophronia - some really lovely names but I would suggest the long forms for bc, and short forms for known names.

Love Edie.

Love edie, Jemima and poss hettie

Hate hate hate Winnie

Gretel is pretty

How about romilly or ottilie?

leaning towards Jemima Alice but still have a soft spot for Gretel ...
A

DS has a friend called Winnie, I love her name! I think Hattie is more traditional as a nn for Harriet, but Hettie is fab too. Great choices, OP!

Edie :)

Love Winnie!!!

Jemima alice is good

I like Hettie as a nn for Hester or Henrietta.