Keeping name ideas a secret from family so need your advice.......

[NicolaOT]

Hi, posted a few weeks ago with some name ideas and everyone was very helpful. I have finally narrowed it down to four...I know still too many!

Edith Grace
Eliza Grace
Penelope Grace
Esther Elizabeth

Obviously I'm a bit stuck on grace as a middle name!

I think my fave at the moment is Penelope but OH thinks this clashes with surname Phillips...I don't agree :-)

Bit not but

Esther Elizabeth is gorgeous

Penelope then Eliza, Penelope goes fine with your surname x

I like all of them but Edith is my favourite.

Eliza or Esther. I like Grace with both.

I find 'EdithPhillips' really hard to say, so I'd avoid that.

Penelope is a lovely name and works well will Phillips.

I love Edith best - goes really well with Grace both in full and shortened to Edie - and great with surname too.

Eliza Grace

I think Grace is very overdone as both a first and middle name. It's the equivilant of Claire/Louise for the late 70s generation.

Edith Elizabeth?
Penelope Eliza?
Esther Eliza?
Penelope Elizabeth?

How long is your surname? I had a friend called Elizabeth Alexandra Surname-with-8-letters and it was a bugger to get on forms so bear that in mind if using Elizabeth, esp with Penelope.

Edie is fine on its own if you like that?