Please could you rate short list of girls names

[bluebell321]

Thought this would be easy but with only a few weeks to go still haven't decided on girls names! Shortlist is below- would really appreciate your honest opinions any other suggestions too would be great.

Skye
Alice
Georgia
April
Sienna

Definitely Alice. It's sweet and classic but not frilly

April.

It's lovely

Alice, Georgia or Sienna for the first name - then use Skye or April for the middle?

Georgia Skye is pretty to my ear!

Definitely Alice!

Georgia and April and okay...

1. Georgia
2. Skye
3. Sienna
4. Alice
5. April

Georgia is a beautiful classic name and not overly popular. Skye and Sienna are lovely name too. Alice is alright, really don't like April.

I love Alice.

Skye is a bit chavvy IMO

Definitely Alice.

Alice is best . Sienna very overdone here a few years ago. April second choice. Skye can be sweet. Georgia not my cup of tea.

1. Alice
2. Georgia and Sienna
3. April
4. Skye

You're getting quite a mixed bag of preferences, aren't you!

Alice or April are the best. Don't like Sienna or Skye

I really only like Alice.

Georgia is the nicest beautiful and classic. Alice is pretty but very popular.
I'm not keen ok the others

Thank you everyone- really appreciate your help. Now to agree with DH....!

Don't really like sienna. I think Georgia and Alice are the nicest.

Which one do you like best and what is your dh choice could you compromise first name/middle name?

Sienna is my fave!!

Suggestions-
Alyssia
Savannah
Freya
Darcie
Matilda / Tilly or Matti

In order of preference:

Georgia
Sienna
Skye
Alice
April

I think they're all pretty, so maybe just wait til she's here and see which suits her best

In order:
Alice

Skye
April
Georgia
Sienna

Much prefer Alice to any of the others. It's pretty and classic, but I don't see it as boring as it has far too many interesting literary and historical associations (Alice in Wonderland) and inspiring namesakes for it to be considered bland. It's more timeless than dull.

Skye is nice and I like the joint nature/island associations, but it is potentially a bit 'hippy-dippy' in feel (which may or may not be a problem!)

April is cute but IMO best kept as a MN - seems too random for a non-April birth and too obvious as a FN for an April baby.

Georgia I would describe as dull. I've taught millions of them (OK, not literally millions, but it does sometimes feel that way!) It has less of a pedigree than Alice, and is likely to date more quickly. And for me it doesn't have a particularly pleasant sound (not a fan of George either).

Sienna is a real flash in the pan name. I had two Siennas in each of the last two primary classes I taught. Both sets of parents told me that they thought they were being original, and were disappointed to find that it was much more common than they'd thought.

Skye and Sienna are very common in infant schools these days.

I like Alice and Georgia.