Sophie or Katie?

[ruledbyheart]

I can't decide, neither can DP.
Either name will be hyphenated with Rose.
So Sophie-Rose OR Katie-Rose?

Sophie, not hyphenated with Rose.

Why does it have to be hyphenated?

Katherine, shortened to Katie. Katie isn't a name, it's a nn.
Also not hyphenated.

I prefer Katie.

Not mad about it hypenated though not what you asked but I prefer an 'a' ending name for hyphenated names. E.g Ella-rose

I'm not sure why I say this because Katie Rose would make a lovely first and second name!

The hyphenated isn't negotiable as its family tradition although only the first part will be used anyway.

Don't hyphenate. She won't thank you, it's naff thanks, ma and pa.

Sophie.

no hyphen

Katie but I would give Katherine (or Catherine I prefer) as a given name or Kate.

Sophie is very lovely too.

Neither of them hyphenated for me but you didn't ask that lol :)

Kate is lovely

Katie. No -Rose.

If it had to be hyphened, Katie-Fay

I would choose whichever one suits her best. A Katie has a different look from a Sophie.

Sophie Rose or even nicer IMO Sophia Rose.

Why hyphenate if you're only planning to use the first part anyway? (Genuine question)

Catherine Rose, NN Katie is a pretty, classic name.

Good choices in names! Mines Katie and my younger Sis is Sophie :) I personally prefer Sophie out of the two names though! I think Sophia Rose sounds lovely together though

Katherine Rose or Sophie Rose.

The hyphen cheapens both names IMO.