Amanda

[Jusfloatingby]

A friend just called her baby this. I can't decide if it's classical or a bit dated??

It's a baby

Sorry?

It just seems a bit mean spirited to start a thread about an actual baby, rather than a hypothetical discussion of a name.
Might be just me though. Sorry, as you were.

What are you on about? I'm asking what people think of the name, not of the baby.

It's a lovely name :)

I like Amanda.

But I agree with scented.

Still not with you? People are discussing the name Drew Barrymore has given her 'actual' baby and practically every name discussed on here belongs to 'actual' children. .

But there's a difference between 'I'm thinking of naming my baby X, please critique' and 'my friend has already named her baby X, and I think it's a bit naff.'.
Not having a go OP, (I was a grumpy cow yesterday, I shouldn't have commented in the first place) but I just found it a bit of a mean thread.

Why do you feel the need 'to decide' whether you like your friends' name .

For Jesus sake. I was just idly pondering on the name and asked, totally anonymously, what people thought of it. I'm not conducting a poll to present to my friend or anything.

Why do people feel the need to 'decide' whether they like Drew Barrymore's baby name or Reece Witherspoone's. It's just a bit of idle chat about a name.

Some of you really take this forum a little bit too seriously.

Hate it with a passion

I can imagine it being considered very vintage and pretty in about forty years or so. I predict a big revival.

What about calling a baby Almond?

Or more likely Armande! en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armande_Béjart

It was very popular when I was born, don't really like it, but as usual I like the French version, Amandine

Its bleh.

That's the second time I've used that word to describe a girls name (prospective or otherwise) on MN.

I hope there isn't going to be a resurgence of bleh, boring 'too old to be modern, not old enough to be vintage' names.

I know what you mean Titty. It's more a seventies name really. I think it's very pretty but just doesn't have the charm and nostalgia that goes with some of the older names. But as I said, I can see it being considered a lovely elegant vintage name in about forty years.