I don't feel like any girls' names are "It"

[CheerfulYank]

Luckily I have until the end of May. :o But I like to have my ducks in a row.

Names I like, but don't seem right:
Caroline
Frances
Louisa
Josephine
Georgia/Georgiana

I like Anna but feel like it's too...plain, maybe? And anyway I'd like to avoid the initials A, M, and S. I liked Philippa/Pippa for a long time but I think everyone would say "Oh like Middleton..." now. :(

Names that are out due to family members/close friends:

Emma
Emily
Kate
Jane
Claire
Vanessa
Ella/any "El" name really
Rebecca
Anne
Hannah
Gabriella
Amelia
Grace
Charlotte
Constance
Samantha (also, I have a Samuel)

I want something recognizable as a name but not something you hear every day! Help, Mumsnetters, help! :)

Felicity
Stephanie
Audrey
Helena
Susannah
Jacqueline

I really love Susannah and it would be a lovely way to honor my MIL who is Suzanne. But I don't like Sam and Susannah together...I'm weird about the same initials.

Yes Blue, no Scarlett. Or Rusty, Amber, Gray, Sienna... or Shittah, as Glaikit has suggested before. :o

Zoe
Joanna
Vivienne
Olivia (much used here, not sure about the US)
Laura
Natalie

I know you said avoid A but...

Annalisa (nn Anna or Lisa)
or Anastasia (nn Anna or Tasia)

Kirsten/Kirstyn
Christina
Amarys
Clara
Marianne
Melody

out of your short list, i like Louisa the best.

what about

Cordelia

Diana

Marta

Margot

Valentina

Tessa