Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to suggest to son he gets a windows OS system rather than a Mac....

57 replies

menopausemad · 28/04/2010 12:50

Son, age 15, and knows everything about everything is quite bright. Just finishing some course work before GCSEs which he will complete this summer. Geeky lad, very computer literate.

Laptop died this morning - can't even get stuff off hard drive when used in a other machine. It turned into an expensive brick overnight.

I am sure everyone can imagine the drama but I will stop there! He wants to replace with an (expensive) Macbook. To be fair he has fancied going Apple for a while but I am worried he will make a quick decision that might not be helpful long term (if he goes for Mac it will be purchased over three years so will have to see him through college). College subjects; physics, maths, electronics, computing and chemistry. The college run both OSs and we have a selection of Windows stuff in the house should he need something that cannot run on Mac in Virtual machine/OS.

So AIBU to try and steer him towards windows? Cheaper, less of a commitment and possible, if he does not like it/has more money in the future. someone else in family will take it over?

Votes please! But if possible also points of argument that I can get him to consider....

OP posts:
Snobear4000 · 28/04/2010 22:57

The only reason not to get a Mac is that you have to go into the awful Mac store where a carefully selected team of good looking, tidy, and carefully multi-racially represented twenty year olds (without a deep knowledge of computers), with trendy, youth accoutrements such as facial piercings and dreadlocks (short, neat dreadlocks), will ignore you for ages if you are over thirty-five, even though you walked in with a thousand quid burning a hole in your pocket and the intention to buy a MacBook Pro.

They'll fawn all over the kids running in to the store to buy a new iPod touch and ignore the best customer in the store!

Anyhow, rant over, I love Apple computers, for these reasons:

The way the OS works, you find yourself archiving things and customising the computer to suit your own personality, more so than on a Windows system.

The computers come with every single thing you would want, software-wise, except the Microsoft office suite, which most people feel they need, although there are alternatives that create Word files and Excel files. The security is tight, and regularly updated, so there is no need to shell out on virus software. There are lots of nice, user friendly and intuitive applications already installed to help you archive music, movies, photos, create movies, edit photos and so forth.

You never have to install a driver for any peripheral.

The customer service is terrific, under warranty (and this can be increased to three years with Apple Care) you can call them any time (I use the US number after hours) for help with anything that goes wrong with the hardware or software. And it is worldwide. Your mac goes bung in Tokyo or Toronto and there's a store there to fix it for you.

One crappy thing is... the hardware has become less reliable in recent years, and after many years of producing bullet-proof laptops, I have heard stories lately of problems with overheating (I think this was solved with the latest MacBooks), batteries dying, amongst other things. I hope this is not the start of a slippery slope in product quality. Anyhow, the guarantee will cover any breakdowns.

Regardless of these reservations, I would always recommend a mac over Windows. They are used extensively in education, the creative industries and more recently at home. Apple are always increasing market share and it is no longer considered a niche product or an "outsider's choice". And yes, it can run almost any application, and for those that are Windows only, Apple can also run Windows.

PrimroseCrabapple · 28/04/2010 23:25

Once you have a student email addy if your college is linked up you get loads of free microsoft stuff, am talking thousands worth.

Operating systems, windows serverm, visio, access you name it, plus the ultimate steal, ultimate office for £40.

(pats lovely free software affectionately)

Most computing folks I know are windows fans, offices use windows.

Macforme · 28/04/2010 23:42

Another mac fan here (think my username gives it away lol)
Our house has an imac (my precious....) two macbooks and two windows laptops (in my defence we have 4 teenagers!) and as each windows dies we replace with macs.

Not even new ones,..my DS2's is an ebay second hand and a few years old..and still great. No virus worries, no 'plug and pray' they just work!
My DS1 uses garageband constantly, I can have a shedload of programmes running and it never slows. I LOVE iphoto, and generally love the simplicity of macs over windows.

Not to mention how fabulous they look... :D

They are horribly expensive but so far my macs are outlasting the windows computers so much that it's not an issue... if your son can run to a mac.. buy mac!!

Ninjacat · 28/04/2010 23:50

I love my mac but I work in the arts so it's essential really.

Don't forget to get your educational discount when buying a computer for a student.

animula · 29/04/2010 00:19

I love Macs BUT

A LOT of my computer geek friends have Lenovo Thinkpads.

apparently they are what you need for computing stuff.

menopausemad · 30/04/2010 10:50

Mibby I can't message you! You have chosen to not accept these. Can you change this please?

OP posts:
menopausemad · 30/04/2010 11:10

Bump for Mibby

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread