Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be silently jubilant about vitupartive email campaign against SIL?

13 replies

tittybangbang · 24/03/2010 10:23

Background: my SIL has always disliked me and my children. Have never understood why - I haven't had words with her, have never criticised her, and have always happily included her in on many family events, including birthdays and Christmas. I've only ever been in her house once in the 15 years she's been with DB - and that was for for a quick coffee with my brother while she was out. She also pretty much ignores all three of my children, won't look at them or address them directly, let alone give them a kiss or a cuddle. I can't get my head around it - I utterly adore her kids and really enjoy seeing them at my mum's.

I've really struggled with her dislike of me over the years - she can't hide her feelings and doesn't make much effort to try. I've got very upset in the past trying to work out what it is she hates so much about me and my children, and at low points over the past year or so, when I've been depressed, I've become overly pre-occupied with it. When I'm feeling strong I can be generous about it and focus on all the things I like about her - she's a good mum, very hard-working and hugely loyal to my brother (with whom I have a loving relationship). I'm getting better at coping with it as the years pass.

Anyway....... mum phoned last night and said that SIL's ex-childminder (who looked after her ds for 2 years full-time), who is also (or was also) a family friend and a close neighbor, has been emailing SIL's friends saying .... not sure, but it's very critical apparently. I suspect this childminder is suffering from a depressive illness - the emailing is very out of character. Now I was aware that SIL had had a major falling out with her, after she'd said she didn't want to look after my nephew anymore due to having another child of her own. My understanding is that this woman has had a very difficult time over the past few years having had two mid-term miscarriages, plus money worries connected with her dh's job. Last thing I heard SIL was crossing the road to avoid talking to her, had blanked her when she'd seen her out with her new baby (the one born after a previous late miscarriage). This childminder also has a child in the same school as SIL's ds, so she has to put up with being blanked on a daily basis. My brother told me that she'd approached him at a school fete last year and sobbed, asking what she'd done to upset SIL and why SIL was blanking her. BTW - the blanking started BEFORE the rogue emails.

Feel ashamed, but was quietly jubilant that someone might have 'outed' SIL as a vindictive cow.

OP posts:
onebatmother · 24/03/2010 10:28

Nah. You've done very well finding her good points I think - am certain that, had it been me, there would been a family-splitting, side-taking, no-going-back stand-up row some years ago. Involving wine.

Really, we need a new 'Am I Being Human' topic, don't we?

tittybangbang · 24/03/2010 10:30

"there would been a family-splitting, side-taking, no-going-back stand-up row some years ago. Involving wine."

Have long fantasised about this scenario.

OP posts:
FabIsGettingThere · 24/03/2010 10:32

As long as it stays silent jubilation.

OrganicHairbrush · 24/03/2010 10:34

You're just being human, honestly.

And I'm sure you're sufficiently grown up to ensure you continue to smirk only from a distance without joining in.

BTW I love the word "vituperative". I think I last heard it in Year 8 Latin lessons at school...

tittybangbang · 24/03/2010 10:39

Shame I typo'd it in the title.

OP posts:
tittybangbang · 24/03/2010 10:44

"And I'm sure you're sufficiently grown up to ensure you continue to smirk only from a distance without joining in."

Seeing DB and SIL at mum's this weekend. Am practicing facial expression for if the issue is aired around the dinner table. Think I will be able to communicate jubilation best by complete silence and poker face.

OP posts:
onebatmother · 24/03/2010 13:51

I think it's extremely unlikely SIL will raise it. Would be very foolhardy I think.

Why isn't your mum involved?

MeMudmagnet · 24/03/2010 14:00

Some people are odd!?!

Have you never spoken to your DB about it? Surely he must have some idea what the problem is. Or your Mum?

(Very satisfying that Karma has caught up with her though )

GoldenSnitch · 24/03/2010 14:20

Had to look up "vituperative", that's a new one on me!

I think you sound like an absolute saint for not having caused a major family row over her behavior. You deserve a little quiet merriment now it's all come back to bite her on the ass

tittybangbang · 24/03/2010 15:01

"Have you never spoken to your DB about it? Surely he must have some idea what the problem is. Or your Mum?"

Mum is very offended by SIL's behaviour towards me and my children, but doesn't want to cause a rift by airing her views to SIL. Mum adores DB's children and wants to see them as much as poss. If she falls out with SIL that might prove a problem. SIL has a track record of being vindictive towards people who challenge her - she's left several jobs after rifts at work.

DB is a very beloved b, but he's weak and can't cope with confrontation. I think he's also baffled by SIL's behaviour. He tries to pretend it's not happening, that he hasn't noticed. He could invite us around to their house even if she's not happy about it, but for some reason he doesn't, even though we are very close. He also gets on with my DH like a house on fire. They were friends before I met DH, and go out together after work sometimes. It's all very vexing really.

OP posts:
Pikelit · 24/03/2010 15:33

I love "vituperative". As a word, not a character trait, mind.

I'm always baffled by people who can sustain these pointless feuds but do understand why the rest of the family might choose to stand back and not make things worse. It's vile when you are on the end of the vituperation but it is even nastier if a family finds itself split as the result of one person behaving badly. Because this sort of split can carry on down the generations and never actually get resolved.I say this as someone who, at the age of 12, suddenly lost contact with half of my family as a result of my grandmother falling out with an aunt.

I'm not normally someone who wishes ill of people but I suspect I would be getting some silent jubilation out of the OP's SIL's downfall!

brassband · 24/03/2010 19:10

SILs are often jealous of the other women in their DHs life.Why do you think there are so many vitriolic posts from DILs about their MILs on here?

Re the children -The difference is that your DBs children are your flesh and blood and your DC aren't related to her

ConnieComplaint · 24/03/2010 20:14

My SIL is like this too

She has caused a family split though.

Db married her about 5 years ago & he moved to her part of the world (about 70 miles away from home).

He works full time and on a Saturday also then when DB wanted to visit our mum on a Sunday she said he out our mother before her. I can sort of see her point, but she saw him every evening & morning, my mum is almost 70 & he has always, even before marrying SIL, spent a couple of hours on a Sunday evening at mum's with the rest of us.

We haven't seen him since Christmas Eve. The last time we visited them in their house, she put her coat on & walked to Asda (she can't drive). This was deliberate - Asda is 5 miles away.... When I pointed this out to me DB he just went silent & said all her family can be strange.

It's good that your still v.close to your DB though, I love my brother, he's Godfather to my ds, but because she doesn't like him visiting anywhere, we hardly see him.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page