Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why anyone would want to watch one born every minute

62 replies

princessparty · 17/02/2010 17:42

I mean it ain't pretty and is about something that happens thousands of times every day and has done for millions of years.Boring, boring, boring !

OP posts:
mummytowillow · 17/02/2010 20:03

I'm the complete opposite, so you may think I'm crazy BUT I love watching birth programmes because I feel I missed out on so much?

I had IVF treatment, new I was only having one child (couldn't go through it all again) planned a water birth etc etc and got an unplanned C section, thought I was going to die on the table and then ended up with PND. Sounds awful but I'm over it now, but watching other people have the birth I wanted makes me smile, in fact I usually cry all the way through it (am I crazy)

mummytowillow · 17/02/2010 20:04

But, I will confess to torturing myself a bit, wondering 'what if' 'was it my fault'

nickytwotimes · 17/02/2010 20:05

I watch it.

I am pg again atm, otherwise wouldn't bother.

I am nosy and the babies are cute.

woollyjo · 17/02/2010 20:07

I've not seen it but a few folk without kids have mentioned it saying 'wow I never knew what you folk (those of us with kids)go through'

LittleSilver · 17/02/2010 20:08

I am sorry you get flashbacks Riven. Have you had any support for them?

Littlefish · 17/02/2010 20:12

And PrincessParty does it again.....

bibbitybobbityhat · 17/02/2010 20:13

I do completely understand why people would want to watch it (not my cup of tea, but, I do get why Mumsnetters might want to watch) - but I do not understand why we need to have 3 or 4 threads permanently in active convos about it!

sarah293 · 18/02/2010 07:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

30andLurking · 18/02/2010 07:50

Well for those of us just starting to contemplate becoming parents, I think it's an amazing show. The chance to see real women in labour, not enacting some Hollywood notion of the perfect birth or some sensational shock-doc on birth traumas, seems pretty invaluable to me. I've read so many complaints on here that there's not enough real genuine information about the kind of births the majority of women go through - in hospital, with minor or no intervention, rather than horror stories or NCT floating on fluffy clouds - that for Channel 4 to show them seems like genuinely brilliant old-fashioned public service broadcasting.

BelleDameSansMerci · 18/02/2010 07:51

Riven...

ssd · 18/02/2010 07:54

YANBU

I can't watch babies being born, never have been able too

to me its like a horror film, all blood and guts

woollyjo · 18/02/2010 08:33

I can't watch it for similar reasons Riven DD2 was stillborn at term - we had no idea her heart had stopped beating in the hours before I went into spontaneous labor. Before that had happened I probably would have watched it.

gorionine · 18/02/2010 08:43

I can think of plenty reasons not to watch it,
"boring" was not one I had in mind.

GetOrfMoiLand · 18/02/2010 08:53

I have missed this programme which I thought was a shame, as I really want to watch it.

I love watching births. Personally I had a lovely time giving birth to dd and think it is a great thing to watch.

God knows how the OP can say it is boring.

memoo · 18/02/2010 09:06

Riven, it is NOT your fault! xxxxx

I couldn't stand to watch it either. I had such a hard time with DD (5months) that watching somebody have a beautiful, natural birth just twists the knife for me.

I have tried watching programmes like that before and ended up in floods of tears so tend to avoid them!

OP uabu though, If you really don't understand why some people would find these kind of programmes interesting then you are seriously lacking in something.

30andLurking · 18/02/2010 09:26

By the way, Riven and others who have suffered traumatic births, I don't mean to imply that your experiences shouldn't be shown/discussed as well, I just mean that because statistically most women are likely to have a birth that isn't at either extreme end of the spectrum, then this programme is really valuable. Not trying to belittle what any of you have been through at all!

acebaby · 18/02/2010 09:37

OP - are you my DH ? Personally, I was glued to it and very moved by all the births. I thought it was considerably more exciting than the gadget show or top gear (DH's favourites) and somewhat more exciting than come dine with me. Whether it beats masterchef remains to be seen. So YABU.

But I can see that it could be traumatic for some people to watch. However, I thought it gave an accurate picture of what is like on a busy maternity unit (eg not enough midwives or anaesthetists, mistakes with food service etc but everyone swinging into action when there is an emergency)

CloudDragon · 18/02/2010 09:50

Hardly boring compared to half the crap they put on telly (big brother / snooker / Emmerdale to name some of the programmes I would used to tackle insommnia)

It did make my toes curl as I'm 30 weeks preg and had blanked out how bad even a good birth can be.

Also a reminder of how little support labouring women are given.

PeachyPeachyEverPreachy · 18/02/2010 09:57

I rather like it, brings back memoties and Dh enjoys it too.

Each tot heir own.

PeachyPeachyEverPreachy · 18/02/2010 10:18

Riv you had no way of perparing for what would happen to your lovely DD and there is nothing to blame yourselffor.And she was always a baby- the people who saw her as anything else were wrong,plain and simple.

I had PTSD after my first birth, not as bad as your experience but stillscary- basically I was in seven times with high BP, they'dsend me in,MWat main unit wouldlagh at me and keepme in thens end me home. On one occasion Registrar actually shouted at me for selfadmitting even though I hadn't, BP had been 145 and MW at the MLU had sent me straight over.

At 38 weeks MW decided I was very smallfor dates and sent me in,I lay in an antenatal unit alone listening whilst MW outside yelled at my MW for sending in a waste of space case and sent me home.Afewdays klater my BP topped 160 and DH arried me virtually unconscious to the MLU (I always ahd to go tehrefirst as main unit a fair distance away). I ahd a fit on the table, and MWcalled main unit in tears to beg forme to have a CS (I couldnt response but can remember all this) but was refused as it was that nervous woman again. They blue lighted me to the hospital, where an Obst checked meover (sameone every bloosy time) and toldme I would be sent home except it was 3am so I should go home first thing next day.

Next day no word from anyone but sent for a scan.

Ignored again with no discharge, got back from shower next day to be passed a message that baby had not only stopped growing but had lost weight, emergency induction was to be started immediately.

Called Dh, and they started but toldme it would take 3 - 4 days.

They refused Dh access to unit even though I wascontracting, but he barged past thank goodness, just intime toseme refusedpain relief asthe hand overwas too busy.... he took over, I wasgiven peth and after hand over wheeled to labour ward.

They thought I might have HELLP by this time but ds1'sheart trate was fdropping so they didn't know what to do- HELLP contraindicated a CS, and the ehart rate scared them into wanting one. They lost all the bloods to check for HELLP, and it took IIRC several hours to get retests done. Allthis time I waspretty out of it and begging for an epidural(what with induction and high BP it was recommended) but Anaesthetist was too busy.

Dh was petrified, nobody would talk to him and he thought he would lose us both.

Bloods came back clear but then the anaesthetist was still too busy for CS. We didn't know they wereworried about ds1's BP at this point but notes clearly satte that.

Just as they went into fullscalepanic mode I waslucky and went from 5cm to 10cm in one contraction (did with alllabours in fact) and he was born fine but very small for fullterm at just over 5lb,scanssuggest he'dlost 1lb in utero over a few weeks.

I ahd a brief debriefwhen two staffmemebersassureedme 'you didn'treally want intervention anyway'andI assured them I really had done, but otherwise it wasn't until I was expecting ds2 and booked in elsewhere that I got a Obst toreview my notes and explain exactly what ahd ahppened and confirm that it was indeed eclampsia. having that made such an enormous diference.

Sincethen I have had 3 births,ds2 at a sort of hybrid unti that could do CS's but not neonatalcare,ds3 at the original hospital after my HB went tits up (boo) and a HB and every one has been a better experience. i'vefound that watching other bitryths on TV etc has helepd enormously to enable me to file ds1's delivery under 'badly mismanaged'rather than my fault IYSWIM.

DS1 is ten now but I ahd PTSD afterwards and it wasn't picked up on as I had nothing to compare it to in terms of a 'normal' birth. The ubnit I delivered in has changed massively,afriendlost her babay there was that was admitted as their fault but after changes sis had a pre eclampsia baby there and had marvellous help,both in antentaland for a month in NICU afterwards. But I neededthe experience of what was normal to enable myself to say hey it was OPK to be upset, it was a bad case, you're not over reacting at all.

LadyRabbit · 18/02/2010 17:11

Not given birth yet, but with any luck I will be in a few months' time. So I have been watching it to get a more real sense of what it's going to be like.Riven I can see why if you had a bad experience this wouldn't be ideal viewing. I may feel the same way soon, I don't know what will happen, but it's been useful for me already. I made DH watch some of it the other evening (he really didn't want to) and since then he has had his eyes opened a bit.

You know, with all this money the government spends trying to get teenagers to use contraception - if someone had shown me an episode of OBEM when I was 12 or 13, I would have kept my legs crossed until I was 30. I wonder if, without traumatising teens, instead of the baby dolls that a lot of schools give students to look after, we couldn't be upfront and make them realise quite how physical it all is? Maybe they do that in schools now, but sex-ed in my day (God, I sound antique) really skated over the reality of childbirth and pregnancy.

2shoes · 18/02/2010 17:18

riven don't blame your self.
I had dd in hospital, perfect birth, yet she still came out not breathing and is now severely disabled. so I don't watch programmes like this one.
but it wasn't my fault or yours(morelikely someone elses iynwim)

MABS · 18/02/2010 17:43

not your fault at all Riven, my two wouldn't be alive without the hospital, but then the 3 i lost in between sadly aren't. No-one's fault tho, taken me a long while to see it wasn't mine, still have my black days i assure you

Naaah, can do without this type of programme

LauraIngallsWilder · 18/02/2010 17:47

Riven - I agree, dont blame yourself

mosschops30 · 18/02/2010 17:51

I agree with riven. I couldnt bear to watch this due to recent traumatic birth. It would be too upsetting.
However I dont know how you can say birth is boring, how can it be boring see someone come in to this world, its a miricle however it happens.