Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel totally deflated by DHs reaction to this?

37 replies

TotallyAndUtterlyPaninied · 19/01/2010 20:37

It's his 30th soon and he never likes anything I buy him as a present and on birthdays/christmas he looks disappointed and I look heartbroken as I tried to get it perfect IYSWIM. I know he's keen to go on holiday but money's tight and we have a 20 mo and one due next month.

I picked out a log cabin holiday in England with a big outdoor hot tub and loads of facilities etc. Plus it was affordable. His birthday is October so I thought I'd do that and give him a suprise birthday party on his actual birthday.

Then he'd mentioned something about not wanting to holiday in England in winter. So I had a long think and decided I'd arrange the family log cabin holiday for us in summer and then do the suprise party and potential a night or two away for just us two in October. Now this would mean some serious saving but I thought it'd be lovely and he's worth it. He's pretty much super husband and he always manages to get everything spot on. Plus he's very loving, a good dad and husband and looks after us all really well, particularly with me having such a difficult pregnancy at the mo.

He said if we holiday in England it's got to be south but we're right up north so that'll be a nightmare drive with the kids. So I went for sort of the middle of England and finally showed him. I'd thought about it for two weeks and thought he'd be over the moon at the prospect.

He looked like I'd suggested we drink our own piss. So I showed him the pictures. He said it's not far enough south and it will be cold. He was totally unbothered. So that has now scuppered my plans of a summer holiday and potentially scuppered the plans for the couple of nights away for us as surely he won't be overly keen on that either?

So what am I meant to do? I thought for once I'd finally hit the nail on the head but he's totally unimpressed.

I wonder why I get it wrong all the time and what the hell I should do for a holiday (if anything) and his birthday?

OP posts:
youwontknowme · 20/01/2010 12:08

i was going to ask if he was a libra??
i am notoriously difficult at buying presents for.

pooexplosions · 20/01/2010 12:11

I don't think hes sounds as bad as everyone is making out, there are a lot of people who would hate to have a holiday booked for them without consulting, especially on in England.

Bumblingbovine · 20/01/2010 12:16

I would HATE somebody booking a holiday for me. Holidays are really important to me and I want to have a say in the details. Dh tries but he always gets something wrong because quite franky he has no interest in holidays so just books something quickly.

I don't like surprise holidays or getaways at all. All that pretending to be grateful for the thought when inside I'm thinking 'What I REALLY would have liked was ..." I know it sounds really ubngrateful and a bit controlling (which it is) but it is nonetheless how I feel.

I think I might have done what your dh did. Complained and then felt bad about it.

Why not stop trying to please him and just ask him what he would like in the future? Half the fun of a getaway for me is in the planning and researching

TotallyAndUtterlyPaninied · 20/01/2010 13:07

Youwontknowme- Yep, he's libra! But then we both are and I am a firm believer that if someone has thought a present through, it's the best thing ever, even if it's dog shit with sequins on IYKWIM.

For those who asked, the website was hoseasons.co.uk and they have loads of different things.

I hadn't actually booked the holiday, I'd just picked every last detail. I'd got a little shakey at the thought of him saying it was crap after I'd paid so that's why I'd asked him. But he's totally come round to the idea now which I'm really chuffed about. We do actually seem to have the misconception that the south is burning hot around here- every one in town seems to go to Cornwall in the hope of a bit of sun

Fortunately I know the party is the right way to go as his whole family are in on it and he's all for friends and family all being together at things IYKWIM. Now had I suggested 50 of us go to the hol, he'd have been extatic

He did suggest his sister and her fiance come to the holiday but I pointed out that after an hour or 2 with her fiance we always leave saying 'he's an arse' so an entire week with him would be disasterous. So there are still some details to consider I guess.

OP posts:
YorkshireRose · 20/01/2010 15:01

It always seems to be raining in Cornwall!

ageing5yearseachyear · 20/01/2010 15:04

tell him the budget for family holiday. tell him budget for birthday. leave it for him to sort out. go to whatever he arranges and enjoy it.

TheRomanceOfItAll · 20/01/2010 16:58

He sounds very ungrateful. I wouldn't trouble yourself any further. Get him a subscription to 'Total Carp' magazine and let him look a truly shit present in the face.

Triggles · 20/01/2010 17:42

A bit mixed, really. Sounds like communication is the main issue though. To be fair, I wouldn't want DH to pick out a holiday and then surprise me with it either. And I detest surprise parties. But that's just me. I'm not certain I understand why he's so fussed about the south, but oh well, he has a right to his opinion, I suppose. We haven't had a holiday in over 5 years, so I would say that DH & I would be grateful for an evening out at this point, much less a nice holiday somewhere "away" regardless of where it is.

scrimble · 20/01/2010 18:32

That was such a lovely, thoughtful gesture. I'd feel just the same way as you. He sounds ungrateful, though he may not mean to.

His turn to make an effort.

PfftTheMagicDragon · 20/01/2010 18:40

I would let him sit in the shed for his birthday.

Honestly, does he think the south is the fucking Med? It's not that much warmer down south that in the Midlands and you can't guarantee the weather any way!

I guess it depends on whther he is an organiser or not. DH is not and would love it if I booked us a holiday, but I would hate it as I like to be in control of all the details and the child arrangements.

Still,m you went to a lot of effort, but really, if he can't even put on a happy face when he gets a birthday present he needs a kick in the knackers.

scrimble · 20/01/2010 18:52

"...if he can't even put on a happy face when he gets a birthday present he needs a kick in the knackers."

Well put PTMD!

almostreal · 20/01/2010 19:00

YANBU I would go without him if that his attitude, leave him alone on his birthday then maybe next year will appreciate his efforts.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page