Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that this Nativity Play was:

15 replies

WeThreeNinks · 16/12/2009 19:23

(a) Hilarious

(b) Needing of the MN Gavel

OK , it was lovely as they always are, I cried lots at the acting and the singing and the little innocent children as you do. Especially the angels with their snow-white robes, tinsel and filthy mud-stained trousers and trainers.

And some of the voices were wonderful and it was very inclusive.

The staff and children all worked incredibly hard too, I could tell. Concerts were my thing as a teacher.

However, several things made my jaw drop and I'd like to know if they are usual for Christmas plays aimed at children from 5-11.

Firstly, the child playing Mary was draped in a green school tapestry curtain. I may well be culturally biased here but after 38 years of Our Lady in blue it struck me as odd.

Secondly there was a scene from the Gospel which is usually overlooked in school plays following the lovely one where Mary accepts that she is going to be the Handmaiden of the Lord.

It had its own scenery - Joseph's bedroom, where he ruminates about the parentage of his betrothed's offspring and considers not marrying her.

"Surely she could have thought of a better excuse" says he!

Then follows a song from Joseph's POV saying that he'll be a "Dad" to the Christ Child. Sung by the infants

All the nativities I've ever seen have diplomaically skimmed over this bit. It isn't necessary surely, Joseph is naturally as pleased as Mary that she is carrying a Special Baby surely? No need for Jeremey Kyle and his all-important DNA results at Christmas! Perhaps it's the modern way.

Fast forward to the scene with the shepherds on the hillside.

Shepherd 1: The sky looks so different tonight, a strange kind of light, as if anything could happen...

Shepherd 2: Have you been eating those mushrooms again?

Accusing poor Reuben of having been at the old fermented grape juice isn't enough?

Go on tell me, was it or ? I'm undecided.

OP posts:
coldtits · 16/12/2009 19:25

it was

mumto3boys · 16/12/2009 19:26

definitely. Bit of adult humour is great IMO!

Morloth · 16/12/2009 19:26

That sounds great TBH, I would have been choking down the giggles.

nativity

LauraIngallsWilder · 16/12/2009 19:27

Funny I guess for adults
But not suitable for the kids imho

Why do so many schools insist on tinkering with the gospel story?

A school local to us had some of the kids dressed as spoons............

CirrhosisByTheSea · 16/12/2009 19:32

I don't like children used to provide adult humour - it's a bit gross really when they don't know what they're saying. Far nicer when the 'actors' and the audience are all sharing the same thing. I just think it's un-kind and a bit vulgar really.

the green clothes for mary wouldn't bother me at all, nor would the thing about Joseph accepting the baby - kids think about this stuff, no harm in including it imo! But the mushrooms comment was tasteless.

sarah293 · 16/12/2009 19:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

WeThreeNinks · 16/12/2009 19:34

PMSL at the spoons

OP posts:
RubysReturn · 16/12/2009 19:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AliGrylls · 16/12/2009 19:41

It sounds classic. Definitely give it .

I love the bit about Joseph being unsure of the parentage. And also Reuben being on the mushrooms.

MadamDeathstare · 16/12/2009 19:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

morningpaper · 16/12/2009 19:43

lol @ spoons

We had lots of jokes about sherry and Ofsted

I do think that occasionally ambition tramples somewhat over coherence and I'm not convinced it's worth sacrificing the entire Autumn term for... but still....

bran · 16/12/2009 19:46

Mary didn't wear blue in DS's nativity. I always thought that was only a Catholic thing. Mind you, I went to protestant school and never had a nativity at all, so perhaps in Ireland only the Catholic schools do them at all. I think DS's nativity today is the first one I've ever been to.

I wouldn't be keen on a tongue-in-cheek mushroom/drug reference by children so YANBU. They don't have any children older than year 2 as it's a fairly new school, but they still had some interesting dialogue. "What's that in the sky? It looks like a giant sparkling teacup." The head said afterwards that it was one of several things that wasn't in the script.

SingleMum01 · 16/12/2009 19:48

I saw a nativity last night where 4 elephants visited the baby Jesus!!!!

secretgardin · 16/12/2009 19:49

at least they are still doing nativity, even if it veers a bit off course we went to ds' one yesterday and it sounds quite similar to yours. must admit that i (as well as everyone else i spoke to) enjoyed the added humour and so did the children who worked incredibly hard and loved all the laughter and audience involvement. much better than watching a 'winterfest' (too pc to call it christams) show

secretgardin · 16/12/2009 19:51

oohps - christams?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page