Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not like Harry Potter?

59 replies

FlamingoOfTheShineyCult · 22/07/2009 17:41

OP posts:
CyradisTheSeer · 22/07/2009 19:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

woozlet · 22/07/2009 19:49

YABU, the books are ace!

5Foot5 · 22/07/2009 19:53

I think the first three are the best actually. It seems to me that in those she was still just writing it for children and probably having to listen to her editor too.

After that it had started to become established as more of a kiddult thing and I think it shows that she was trying to write for both audiences. Also it seems that her editor just let her do what she liked by then. Books 4 and 5 would certainly have been better if someone had taken out a red pen and made her take out all the waffle.

Goober · 22/07/2009 19:55

YABVVVVVU
and wrong.
You are wrong.

Merrylegs · 22/07/2009 19:57

Ah, good. Time to trot out my HP theory...

When JK was touting the book around, the children's book scene was saturated by 'series' - Animal Ark, Goosebumps, Horrid Histories - books on bookshop shelves were sorted according to series, not authors.

Then along comes HP - this old fashioned school story -and Bloomsbury took a punt.

It worked!

Parents were fed up with 'made up' series. They wanted good old fashioned authors again - this was the CS Lewis, Noel Streatfield, Phillipa Pearce, generation. JK Rowling tapped into this nostalgia; this yearning for stand alone tales.

And then she had to go and ruin it by penning aeons more of the bloody thing. She should have stuck with the one. Much classier. But ho hum. Cash cows were ever thus milked.

However, thanks to HP, publishers backed the author-led book again and children's publishing became much more adventurous again.

And now, just when there seems a tremendously exciting climax to my theory and The Big Truth is about to be revealed......

...everything's gone black. And lo. I have woken up in the hospital wing....

Again.

ObsidianBlackbirdMcNight · 22/07/2009 20:01

YABVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVU

AbricotsSecs · 22/07/2009 20:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Sidge · 22/07/2009 20:05

Nope. Not a fan.

I read the first couple of books and thought they were pretty awful, but persevered as everyone said they were worth sticking with.

Got half way through the third one and thought sod this, life's too short. Gave up on them and have never regretted it.

Have watched a couple of the films half-heartedly (ie DH watches them on Sky whilst I MN) and think they are pretty awful too.

But then I couldn't finish a Tolkien book (dire) and the LOTR films bore the pants off me.

I am obviously not a fantasy fan

LongtimeinBrussels · 23/07/2009 15:45

I love the HP books and like the films but my dh would certainly say YANBU (well he would if he liked mumsnet any more than he liked HP ).

New posts on this thread. Refresh page