Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Susan Boyle should be withdrawn from the BGT final?

79 replies

JasperParrot · 29/05/2009 14:11

She has apparently been taken to a safe house because she cannot cope with the stress.

She has been seen by a psychiatrist.

Now while I admit that I hate all the publicity and the plugging of her to boost her popularity, I think that she is clearly not equipped to be able to deal with this, and it will only get worse.

It is IMO irresponsible to allow her to continue in this competition. Clearly she does not have the mental capasity to cope with all that has been thrown at her, and someone should be taking responsibility and pulling her out of there.

OP posts:
amberlight · 30/05/2009 06:44

ASD isn't a mental health condition , not that it would greatly matter if it was - I'm not in the least worried by either in any of my friends - I only see people as people. But it isn't. It's a difference in brain wiring pattern - a bit like the difference between an Apple computer and a PC computer. Same basics, but they won't always communicate well together.

Or to look at it at a different way, it's no different in principle to you going out on the street and watching two cars go by:

Along comes a family hatchback car, full of shopping and kids, gets over the road bump outside, continues on its way. It's built for families and local roads and shopping.

Behind it, a Formula One racing car. Only room for one person, no room for more than a toothbrush inside, difficult to start, requires some specialist handling, rather noisy, can't get over the road bump at all because the car is only about an inch off the ground.

If you were to say "cor, that looks just like a Formula One racecar!", would it be an insult, or an observation? It's not a broken hatchback car, it's a different sort. Not very compatible with roads and families, but a different sort.And often an extraordinary talent - in the case of Formula one cars, going at incredible speeds round a flat track.

Same principle with ASDs. Often no room for more than one person in our lives because of the brain wiring difference, nor for much everyday 'luggage', unable to get over relatively small bumps in life, temperamental to drive, can be noisy, but not just a broken 'normal person' (not that there are any normal people, of course,but you know what I mean). And sometimes an extraordinary talent.

And yes, I've studied a very wide range of sources over quite some weeks now. The rocking in interviews was interesting, the being described as very eccentric, the relationship problems, that she is actually very quick with words if she knows what she's going to be asked, it's all simply interesting to me as someone with an ASD myself. I like her very much, FWIW.

watsthestory · 30/05/2009 07:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

SBNAS · 01/06/2009 17:45

Hi amberlight,
I work for The National Autistic Society press team and really liked your explanations of ASD.
Would be good to speak to you more about this if you were interested.
I tried to message you but couldn't as I don't think you accept private messages.
Could you get in touch with me?
Many thanks

LightShinesInTheDarkness · 01/06/2009 18:02

Acccording to the news, Susan has had to be admitted to The Priory. What a dilemna.
She chose to go to the BGT audition, but she cannot be blamed for the relentless publicity because she sang so well.
Poor woman. Pay her a tidy sum, let her spruce up her house and have a nice holiday. Then leave her alone.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread