Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up DP's diet with him? or should I leave him be?

31 replies

LoveMySorrow · 21/04/2009 12:27

I have only been with DP a few months so am reluctant to bring up his diet with him, I'm sure most would say it's none of my business but I'm genuinly worried. And to be honest, it's putting me off getting any further involved with him.

Before I knew him properly, he had a gastric band fitted to help him lose weight. He was morbidly obese and in danger. He then lost weight very quickly and is now down to 16 stone. He lost around 12 stone in weight.

Thing is he has managed this simply because he's had no choice. He physically cannot eat more than he needs. But he's still eating crap all the time. He doesn't seem to have changed his attitude towards food at all, he just eats much less because he is physically restricted.

For instance he will eat a packet of crisps for his breakfast or a bacon sarnie. Sausage rolls, chocolates and cakes for lunch, sausages, take-aways etc for dinner...I have raised an eye-brow a few times and he assures me it's all fine as he's no longer eating too much of it. He genuinly doesn't understand what he's doing wrong.

The other day I was at his house and he cooked me a meal. It was lovely, roast pork, veg, yorkshire puddings ... then when he served it out he sat down without any and said "I'll have mine later" surely the whole point of having a meal together is to eat together? Anyway when I went home it occured to me that he'd not eaten anything all day apart from some crisps in the morning. He let it slip later that he didn't have any of the roast dinner when I left, instead he ate an easter egg.

Yesterday he came around to take me to a job interview. He was in very high spirits and said "I'm doing so well with my diet, I'm really pleased with myself" He then went on to say "All I've had to eat today is a packet of crisps ... and I'm not even hungry!" this was about 4pm.

I began to question his vitamin levels and general health eating this way and he got quite defensive and said "I'm doing fine, the nurse said my tests were fine".

When we went shopping, he just bought biscuits, chocolate milkshakes and icecreams.

It is putting me off because I think it makes him appear quite ignorent, surely it's common sense that this is a stupid way to eat? and also, I suppose I feel he should be making more effort. If I was in a new relationship, I wouldn't be stuffing my face with crisps and chocolate every 5 minutes.

When the band is taken out, I'm worried he will just balloon again as all he eats is junk food and he does no exercise.

AIBU to bring it up or should it remain none of my business? I don't want to come across as the nagging woman already but I think it's ridiculous.

OP posts:
BalloonSlayer · 21/04/2009 13:47

It's sad but apparently reasonably common.

this article was in the Times a few months ago about a lady who was desperate to lose weight, had a band fitted privately but still didn't lose a lot of weight because, like the OP's DP, what she did eat was chocolate and crap.

LauriefairycakeeatsCupid · 21/04/2009 13:50

He may have started to overeat because of unhappiness in the marriage but he continued to eat up to 28 stone.

As soon as the band is taken out if he doesn't address his emotional issues surely he will just eat up to his maximum (like he's doing now)

Do you think he is still an emotional eater or do you think it's 'just' nutrition?

solidgoldshaggingbunnies · 21/04/2009 14:25

He has an eating disorder, end of. He needs psychological help. Now you could decide to take it on board, treat him as a project and support him through it, but if you do, he will dump you at the end of it because he will think of you as a therapist rather than as a partner. And it will be bloody hard work, for which you are probably not trained anyway (obviously I don't know if you have any experience/training as a counsellor or dietitican). Do you really want to take this on?

2rebecca · 21/04/2009 14:27

I just think blaming an unhappy marriage for your gross obesity is as simplistic and unlikely as blaming your unhappy marriage for your alcoholism, gambling, drug addiction etc.
It takes 2 people to make an unhappy marriage anyway.
This guy sounds as though he needs an awful lot of help if he's ever to have a normal relationship with food.
I think if a woman goes into a relationship with a guy like this and thinks that if she makes him happy everything will be OK they'll be disappointed.
There's being "all heart" and there's being realistic.

LoveMySorrow · 21/04/2009 14:37

I think I'm going to break it off I've just posted in relationships. It's not going to work like this.

Thanks for all the replies.

2Rebecca - I understand what you mean, I also have little patience for people who blame everything on someone or something else.

OP posts:
Sassybeast · 21/04/2009 14:37

I don't think that YABU at all and I suppose for me the question would be if you want to commit to a relationship with someone who has such complex issues with food, particularly if that will impact on your kids in the future ? It sounds as if he is seeing all the 'right' people - but if the professionals can't help him to develop a healthy relationship with food, can you devote a huge part of YOUR relationship to it. At the end of the day, he is (for whatever reasons - I'm not judging) causing immense damage to his physical health and probably shortening his lifespan. In the same way that I could never marry a smoker for example, I'd really have to question if it was fair on me or my kids to carry on. i suppose the only way of finding out is to try and have a really honest conversation with him and see what vibes you get ? Good luck - it's not an easy one.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page