Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm angry with my mother, I know it's probably unreasonable

59 replies

Mandragore · 22/03/2009 15:18

We see each other several times a week, and she helps look after my children if I have an appointment, plus we speak on the phone quite often. She is generally very supportive but I have had issues with her in the past, thinking she is controlling and quite toxic. We just keep a fairly harmonious relationship mainly as I need her help, honestly.

Anyway last week my children were quite ill. Both were being sick and I was up constantly all night for several nights, clearing up, in a sort of relay between them and the washing machine and bathroom, feeding the baby etc etc. I wasn't getting a break but was coping. I rang her and we had our usual brief chat, during which I asked if I might call her to come round if I became ill and couldn't manage with the children.

She sounded really dubious and grudging about it, and wouldn't give a definite answer just saying she was afraid of having to take time off work as work is importantto her and she wants to look committed (she is committed and they know she is, she already does an extra day a week at the moment). Of course I understand and I don't begrudge her wanting to keep her attendance at the top, but I have nobody else I can ask to help if I am ill.
I have a few friends but they are all married and frankly if I was ill I would not want to ask one of them to come and look after me, as I would be worried about passing something on to them and their children. Actually I have an agreement with my best friend that we don't meet if the children are ill. We're upfront about this.

I made it very clear I would only ask if things were desperate, and eventually she said Ok she would help if it was life or death but would prefer it if I had 'something else in place'. We have discussed this before, I have found out about homestart, but they don't provide emergency cover, just a once-a-week thing so it wouldn't help much if I was suddenly ill.

I accepted her feelings on it and we left it - but I asked her not to come round despite her offering to, on her days off, as I didn't want her to catch what the children had got. She was very blase about it, saying 'well I saw them last week, I'll be Ok' but I know if she got ill I'd feel terrible. So I insisted and managed alone. It was fine, I didn't get ill, and the other day when the children were much better, she came round and helped me with some cleaning, which again I felt worried about but she insisted.

This morning I had a phone call from my father saying mum was ill with a tummy bug. I'm not sure why he rang to tell me. He's like that. I said I was sorry and rang her just now to see how she was.
She told me how horrible it is and how awful she is feeling, and obviously thinks it is what my kids have had, despite the fact I kept her away during the worst of it, and I haven't had it myself.

She has done this once before - came to help when Iand ds had a bug, came down with it the next day and made me feel really really guilty. I am not saying she has got ill deliberately but the way she is about it feels as though she is saying 'see, it's your fault'

Why do I feel like this? I can't figure it out but it definitely feels like she is blaming me when she was keen to come round all the time, and I was so careful not to let her. I feel like I can't win.

Is it her or me?

OP posts:
salome64 · 22/03/2009 15:41

maybe she just wants a bit of sympathy from you, and slightly overdoes it, and you feel it as criticism?

And to be honest, she does seem to do quite a lot for you already. Time enough to get help if you do get ill, rather than forcing her to commit to hypothetical mercy dash without her knowing what her work commitments might be that day.

Are you a single mum? I am, and I wouldn't dream of asking anyone to take a day off work to help me even when ds had various episodes of d&v, certainly not asked anyone to take day off work. It just wouldn't occur to me.

Be grateful for the support you get, and try and find a way to resolve those issues you have with her, maybe a bit of counselling might give you a perspective you could move forward from.

salome64 · 22/03/2009 15:42

I meant to say if I were ill too. Just struggle through it.

Nabster · 22/03/2009 15:48

I think you need to have a talk with her tbh. And don't expect to rely on her 100%. Insist next time she doesn't come around when anyone is ill. Remind her she got sick lat time and you don't want the blame again. Be straight.

Comewhinewithme · 22/03/2009 15:49

You sound quite pampered and lucky to have such supportive parents TBH .

I am sorry if that comes across as harsh but many people just have to struggle on when they are ill.

You are a grown woman your Mother can not drop everything for you all the time .

Comewhinewithme · 22/03/2009 15:49

You sound quite pampered and lucky to have such supportive parents TBH .

I am sorry if that comes across as harsh but many people just have to struggle on when they are ill.

You are a grown woman your Mother can not drop everything for you all the time .

CrushWithEyeliner · 22/03/2009 15:51

YABU

cocolepew · 22/03/2009 15:53

I agree with cwwm,(both times) I'd never expect anyone, even a parent, to take days off work to look after me if I was sick. She needs her days for her own sick leave.
YABU.

wotulookinat · 22/03/2009 16:04

YABU

BitOfFun · 22/03/2009 16:04

It sounds a bit like you need to be a bit more assertive and adult in your relationship with her (easier said than done though!)- your reliance on her is making you feel guilty when sometimes you want her to back off. It's hard when you haven't got a partner to get no-strings family support, I know.

I think it's just one of those situations which will sometimes make you feel frustrated- but all you can do really is try and take a deep breath and not let it get you down.

Podrick · 22/03/2009 16:14

Mandragore can you fill in the picture a bit more? How old are your kids, are you a a single mum, do you work?

oldraver · 22/03/2009 16:18

I think you would of been better not pushing her to make a decision on coming to look after you 'if' you were ill, you backed her into a corner really. I would of waited to see if there was an emergency rather than try to plan for something that might never and in fact didnt

psychomum5 · 22/03/2009 16:19

you know, I am soooooo jealous that you have a mum to do that much for you, please appreciate her for that.

I am honestly quite shocked tho that you would have aggreements with your friends to not meet (for fear of passing bugs on), and yet you assume it ok for you to have your mum round to nurse you, giving no thought what-so-ever to the fact that she works, and I assume, nearly an old lady who would not fare so well being ill.

you need a reality check if you think she is being unreasonable.

try living without a mother.

TheCrackFox · 22/03/2009 16:20

YABU.

deanychip · 22/03/2009 16:27

I can see that you would be "irritated" after you asked her not to come round.
However she sounds like she is very useful to you normally.
You are lucky, my parents and ILs dont even offer to have my son (their only gc) for even half an hour while my husband visits me in hospital after my 4th MC.
We manage between us, we have to, never mind help with cleaning etc.

MadameCastafiore · 22/03/2009 16:30

Would you feel any less guilty is she had done what you asked and came and looked after you when you if you got sick and then she got sick herself?

Or would that have been acceptable?

traceybath · 22/03/2009 16:35

I do think you're being unreasonable based on what you've said so far.

I'm not surprised she wouldn't want to take a day off work to hypothetically look after you if you were ill. To be honest i'd have to be at death's door before i asked my DH to take a day off work. Unfortunately one of the most trying and exhausting parts of motherhood is having to carry on when you feel dreadful.

Sorry you've had such a crap time - sickness bugs are hideous. Are you perhaps just feeling really tired as i know this always makes me lose perspective a bit.

aGalChangedHerName · 22/03/2009 16:38

can't believe you would think to ask your mum to come and look after you if you were ill???

How old are you? I have had the 4 of my dc and been ill myself and just got on with it. I don't even ask DH to take time off never mind anyone else.

Strawbezza · 22/03/2009 16:41

YAB totally U in asking her to take time off work (to take a day of her own holiday entitlement, or did you expect her to lie on your behalf and call in sick?) to look after you.

Quattrocento · 22/03/2009 16:41

I'm a YABU as well. You're a grown woman now. Not reasonable to expect someone to take time off work to look after you if you have a tummy bug.

violethill · 22/03/2009 16:47

YABU. Grow up

BitOfFun · 22/03/2009 16:52

< whispers >

Come on OP, drip feed them all something further that makes them all sound like miserable old harridans, I dare you!

I think you know you're being unreasonable, but you've had a tough time recently, and I'm sure we've all had a whinge on here one time or another!

charlie1000 · 22/03/2009 16:53

I think YABU. Your Mum sounds as though she is trying to do what she can to help you but she should not have to compromise her work to look after you if you became ill. It sounds as though she would jump through hoops to help you if she wasn't working but I think you have backed her into a corner with regards to commiting to being at you beck and call.

I'm sure you do value what your Mum does for you but you shouldn't abuse that either by expecting it from her.

As for her getting ill, perhaps she did just want some sympathy and you were slightly upset by thinking she was blaming you? I'm sure she wouldn't have volunteered to help you with housework etc if she was just going to throw it back in your face.

Try giving your Mum the support she deserves too.

piscesmoon · 22/03/2009 16:55

YABU-You can't expect your mother to take time off work to look after you, unless as she told you, it was a matter of life and death. You should count your blessings as she does a great deal for you. I wouldn't call her toxic!

MarlaSinger · 22/03/2009 16:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

troutpout · 22/03/2009 17:00

lol @ bitoffun

Swipe left for the next trending thread