Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that my daughter shouldn't be used for a social engineering experiment?

32 replies

squilly · 12/12/2008 16:55

One of the mums in the playground (who I don't speak to much) asked my dd(7) to her dd's party at the beginning of term. I thought it was odd because dd didn't really play with her child much, particularly as there was a sleepover element, but I got nagged into agreeing and dd went along.

Not much happened til a couple of weeks ago when the mum asked dd to go around and play. Although our kids don't play together much at school, they get on o.k. so again, I said yes. I was later told by a friend that dd was being asked to play/had been invited to the party because this womans daughter has 'gotten in with a bad crowd'. My daughter is thought to be one of the good kids (not bragging...it's just how she's perceived), she's bright, polite and generally well behaved. But you have to say....WTF????

Firstly...how can you have a 'bad crowd' of 7 year olds? We're in a fairly middle class areas and though we have some exuberant kids, they all have redeeming features imo.

Secondly...this woman has made it plain that she wants my dd to play with hers so that her own daugther will start to behave better! Surely people don't really think this way?

Thirdly...why do people feel the need to choose their child's friends for them? I know that friendships are a big part of determining how our kids develop, but surely, letting them choose their own friends is part of the growing up process? Part of the life skills you need to equip them with? Part of being independant?

Are we all really so wrapped up with our kids development though, that we feel the need to pick our kids friends? Am I being unreasonable in being shocked about this? Or should I get with the program and start being my dd's friends for her???

OP posts:
purpleduckUnderTheMistletoe · 12/12/2008 18:41

The first one!

pointydog · 12/12/2008 18:42

I don't think you're being totally unreasonable. I think many parents of the mn ilk take too much to do with their children's friendships, believing they have some control over this area of someone else's life.

You seem to be over-reacting with your anger but I would be a bit too.

skidoodle · 12/12/2008 18:55

all people have flaws. It is not weird to acknowledge those of your children.

I understand what you're saying I think op and I think it is reasonable to be wary of allowing this woman to use your dd in this way.

If it doesn't feel right don't reciprocate

DandyLioness · 12/12/2008 19:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

devoutsceptic · 12/12/2008 19:45

don't assume you know why she's 'not talking to you' right now. Tonight I was seriously blanked by a friend in the playground. I was a bit taken aback and my old insecurities reared up. Came home to an email saying 'sorry I sounded rude but was talking to ds's teacher and he was saying stuff that made me feel very angry. Fill you in later'. Personally, I jump at the chance to invite 'nice' kids to play with mine! It IS a compliment. To me, she sounds worried about her own dd, and maybe she's scared that your dd didn't enjoy herself and reported back negatively. Talk to the poor woman and tell her your dd had a nice time, that you are grateful for the invite and set a date for return match.

nooka · 12/12/2008 19:51

I take it that your dd has a good circle of friends? If so I don't think you should really think so much about this, if your dd is invited again, or wants to ask this child around, then follow that up. Otherwise don't worry about it. You are basing your judgement on a bit of hearsay in any case. Unless the other mum has said to you that she is wanting to encourage the friendship to help her own child, then I really think you are overreaching in your conclusions here.

My ds has had his confidence knocked on the friendship front after we changed schools twice in quick succession. I am encouraging him to make friends on his own, but if I see him playing after school with a child who I think is nice, and where there seems to be some rapport, then of course I am going to encourage that. ds was very reluctant to make the next step, and I can quite see why (he was afraid of direct rejection, whereas it isn't really a problem for me). Helping your child to make friends and grow in confidence is part of parenting.

ChristmasFairySantAsSLut · 12/12/2008 21:33

OP, what is that supposed to mean?

"Firstly...how can you have a 'bad crowd' of 7 year olds? We're in a fairly middle class areas and though we have some exuberant kids, they all have redeeming features imo."

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread