Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with my friend for refusing my offer of a free xmas tree ??

33 replies

IllegallyBrunette · 28/11/2008 17:00

She is absolutly broke, and I mean broke as in house close to being repossessed, piles of bills as high as anything, baliffs at door etc etc.

The situation will soon start to improve as she has just got a fulltime job, but it will be ages beofe they are anywhere near back to normal.

She has 2 kids and so far hasn't brought any xmas presents for them.

Anyhow, last week she mentions that they need to buy a tree as they threw last years away.
I had been thinking of buying a new tree, as although mine is in good condition, I really wanted a pre lit one to save me struggling with the lights on my own again.

So, I went and brought one and when she rang earlier, I asked her if she still needed a tree, she said yes and so I offered them mine.

She said 'oh well we wanted a 6ft one'. I said, 'it is 6ft'.

She then asks me what my new one is like, so I told her, and also told her how much it cost (£28), and she said, 'well we'd like to buy one so we might try and get a pre lit one like you'.

I said it was fine up to them, but the offer was there if they changed their minds.

I know it is their money, life etc, but fgs, why go and spend money on a tree when you cannot pay your mortgage, and you have been offered one for free.

I wouldn't even mind if she had it, used it for one year and then chucked it when they can afford new next year.

OP posts:
georgimama · 28/11/2008 20:08

Maybe she feels a bit tired of being your poor relation and doesn't want any more of your cast offs?

I'm sure you do mean it kindly, giving her clothes for the kids and offering her your 2nd hand Xmas tree, but she may not want your 2nd hand Xmas tree. She may feel that after a tough year she is damn well going to spend £28 on a new one.

JustKeepSwimming · 29/11/2008 08:22

IB - here

ill try to see if our woolies has any left thanks!

CapricaSix · 29/11/2008 08:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Blondeshavemorefun · 29/11/2008 12:41

your friend is insane and YANBU to feel a bit annoyed for hersake or even her kids, the money she could have saved on the tree could have been spent on presents for them, or even a turkey and veg for xmas day lunch

dh INSISTS on a real tree and it drives me insane EVERY year

dropping needles etc

grrrrrrrrrrrrrr

CapricaSix · 29/11/2008 21:36

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

hecate · 30/11/2008 12:05

I think she is not being sensible. But sometimes, when you are in a really bad financial mess and you really NEED help, when that help is offered, you feel so humbled. Like a charity case, like you are being looked down on. Sometimes that can make you turn down help you logically should accept, and yes, even go out spending to 'show' that you can! Does that make any sense? Sometimes the way you offer help can leave the other person feeling not grateful, but humiliated.

onthewarpath · 30/11/2008 15:36

have only read OP

I think the more ineed of help one can be the more encline to refuse help because:

-You do not want to feel like a charity case,

-you are in denial

It is one thing to offer your old tree, being cross because she refused it is BU. It is very nice of you to have given her te opportunity to have a freebee and a very good one by the sound of it, but I do not thing she is ungrateful, she wants to keep her head high and god knows that if in real financial difficulty she will need to be very srtong, she might in time start to accept a bit of help but now seems too soon for her she can still "do it" you have to respect that and support her in a different way.

mm22bys · 30/11/2008 17:03

YABU.

It WAS very considerate of you to offer, but it is her life, her money (or lack thereof), her mess.

Being "judgemental" of other people will not change one thing, in terms of the mess some people have got themselves into.

People lose jobs, etc, but at the end of the day, we do live in a such a consumer-driven society we got to have this, got to have that, at any cost.

Until people change their attitudes, which has to come from within, nothing will change.

OTOH, if we all stop spending, we really will be in a huge mess.....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page