Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

2 AIBU'S please ...?

31 replies

pamelat · 24/11/2008 19:36

Have not had a great day (and its my bday tomorrow too ) but basically will try to give a short version of events.

I am first time mum to a lovely DD (10 months). Was initially a bit precious about her, I am now relaxing in to motherhood and perhaps letting things go that I wouldn't have done a few months ago.

To put a little context in place, I am on a years maternity leave. My mum works full time in a very stressful job (and has poorly parents at the moment) but was a SAHM when I was little.

My DD has had a cold for a week or so. I apply vicks, I give calpol, get up in the night, use the plug in thingy, wrap her up warm etc. Today shopping her nose was running (again) and I had left the wipes in the car outside. My mum pointed this out and I said that I would have to wipe her nose on her coat (gross I know, but we were going within 10 mins and I can wash the coat now, as I am doing in fact). My mum said "oh no she will look like an unloved baby", I corrected her and said "No she will look like a baby with a cold" and she repeated "no, no she will look like no one loves her". I mean FGS!!!!!

So, AIBU to think that thats actually a horrible thing to say?

Secondly, and perhaps more seriously. My GP's are elderly and in poor health. My grandad has spent a month in hospital but is coming home tonight (he isn't looking forward to it because my grandma is completely dependent on care at the moment and he is worried that it will fall to him, currently the family are "sharing" the care).

Today I was witness to a horrible family debate between my mum and her sisters and my grandma where they were very blunt about her future, and all 4 of them ended up in tears. Grandma can be difficult but I really feel for her when they are saying things like "you will end up in care within a month" and "you need to decide whether you want to be here this time next year". (But I know that they are trying to get her to get some independence back)

She needs someone to cook their meals each evening (Meals on wheels doesn't exist in their area) and they won't pay cafe type prices. They are also fussy eaters. My mum has offered to provide meals on 2 nights a week and asked her sisters to do the same but 1 of them has refused, saying that she doesnt want to be tied down with the burden. Do you think this is unreasonable or fair?
They all live within a 6 mile journey of my GP's.

Grandma said that its "payback time" from when they were children, is that an unreasonable thing to say too?! My mum accused of her emotional black mail but I can sort of see where she is coming from (especially having a young baby at the moment)

Arggghhhh, horrible day and the politics of family life.

OP posts:
solo · 24/11/2008 23:05

Snot? pah!

I can't believe that the words 'but 1 of them has refused, saying that she doesnt want to be tied down with the burden' have been typed here. I know we all have our own lives to lead, but surely family ~ especially elderly family needs some sort of commitment or just plain old care? This lady looked after her kids, brought them up and then her grandchildren, why is it so difficult to care for her now she is in need? This angers me so much. My best friend has an 88 year old mother who has become ill. She has three daughters, but it's only my friend who has given up her life style, work and freedom in order to make sure that their mother is looked after. My own dad has cancer and I did not hesitate to insist that I help out with his appointments transportation, or making sure that mum is taken shopping etc. These things ~ especially when spread out between several members of the clan are just small things, but it's what family does.
Sorry for rant, but that really hit a nerve.

mumof2222222222222222boys · 24/11/2008 23:05

HAPPY BIRTHDAY for tomorrow

What a difficult situation. Don't worry about the snot.

With everyone having busy lives, your Grandma needs to compromise a bit. I find it difficult enough to cook proper meals for my immediate family - and we often freeze the leftovers, which taste fine. And I am pretty fussy. Maybe a proper cooked meal once a week (with you all rotating), but then some frozen meals would be appropriate. Is it the company she's after though?

pamelat · 25/11/2008 09:20

Yep I think it is the company.

One of the sisters is divorced and lives alone and has offered to move in for a short while (would save her rent money too) but my granddad has refused (arrghhh!!).

He is now home so will give it a while for the reality to sink in and see if he changes his mind.

I think its awful to say that they are a burden (1 sister said that, not my mum!) but she is on a second marriage and I think she feels she has "wasted" a lot of her life in the first marriage (about 30 years of it) so I think she is desperately trying to reclaim some "me" time now.

OP posts:
solo · 25/11/2008 09:38

I can understand your aunt not wanting to do it all, but to share it between 3 or even more if you and other grandchildren are willing, it needn't be so much to do each week. I've 'wasted' 25 years on crap relationships, but I'd never refuse to do my bit for my parents In fact, I'm doing it all atm because I'm the only daughter and sons(my brother)don't seem to do so much for their parents(IME) The grandchildren are all children still, so would not be expected to do anything.
Perhaps the unwillingness to help family is why society is not what it once was? I think it's very common these days to not want to bother with our 'loved ones' and hope that social services or the NHS will do what is needed. Then when wills are read out, the family is up in arms about the family silver being left to the cats protection league.
I'm not saying that there is a lack of love in your family pamelat, just that generally in society, loyalty is sadly lacking.

onthewarpath · 25/11/2008 10:23

I don't think a child with a bit of snot looks unloved or there would be a lot of unloved children , especially in the winter.

I ,like solo think that children should definitely pay more attention to their elderly parents. I do understand what hecate is saying but it does me a lot. Yes our children do not "owe us" because they did not choose to be born. But, once they have been born and have been (supposidely) well cared for, loved, fed and brought up in a nice manner it should not be a matter of "owing" to them but just showing you care and love your parents.

It would not be fair maybe that just one of the aunt should be the carer, it really should be the familly pulling together. Now, there will probably be times were the family is not able to provide specific care for an elderly poorly person, that is when you should definitely ask for a nurse or a home help to come in and relieve the family a bit (it is hard to be a carer, no one says it is not). Both (family + home help, social services...) can actually be done in a sort of "rota" a few days each or specific times of the day each to accomodate everybody.

I live in the UK and there is one reason and one reason only I would go back to the continent and it would be to care for my parents should they need it. I would not hesitate a second and I know for a fact that DH would support me in that decision. I do have a brother and a sister who do live in their vicinity, but I would feel very left out if not being present and helping and showing how much I love and respect them.

occludo · 11/08/2010 06:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread