Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children walking to school alone: what age is reasonable?

37 replies

gabygirl · 05/11/2008 12:11

Name change regular here. I'm in a mega stew this morning. Basic story:

I've been letting dd1 (9 and a half) walk the 600 yards to school these last few weeks. I watch her from the upstairs window and direct her across the first 3 roads. There's one more to cross at the back of the school that I can't see her cross. Between me losing sight of her as the road turns a corner and the school gates is about..... 300 yards.

Last night ds2 (3) was vomiting on and off through the night. He got up this morning and was sick again. Face gray. Phoned friend and asked if she could drop ds1 (5) at school (same school as dd, but dd goes in 20 minutes earlier) as didn't want to hang around at with a vomiting child, or have to carry ds2 there - my back won't cope and he won't walk.

With some misgivings (don't feel entirely comfortable but had to make a decision in a hurry) decided to let dd walk ds1 round to my friends house, which is directly opposite the school. There is a lollipop man to see them across and we do this route twice a day so they're familiar with it. DD asks if she can knock for her friend on route to school, as she does every morning.

So - off dd and ds go, watched by me until they disappear out of sight. Go downstairs to find ds2 on the pot with the shits. Just as I'm wiping his bum the phone goes. It's dd's friend's mum, furious, telling me she 'doesn't appreciate' me expecting her dd to 'take responsibility' for my ds, that I shouldn't have let my dd walk her brother to my friend's house, and that both my children had now been taken to school by another mum from dd's class who just happened to be passing but decided to put in her tuppence.... She said my children had gone off crying after this other mum had slagged me off in front of them and called me 'stupid'.

So. I phone friend who'd offered to take ds in , thank her for her offer of help and tell her that ds2 is now already at school. I phone other passing mum who took my children in. She promptly apologises for making them cry then tells me she's going in to my dd's classroom to talk to her teacher about why dd's crying. At this point I completely lose my cool and say 'no - you're not doing that - I don't want you interfering any more'. I then phone back dd's friends mother and ask why she didn't phone me in the first place if she wasn't happy instead of making a decision on my behalf and then joining in with another mum to criticise my parenting choices. She put the phone down on me.

Now dreading turning up at the school gate to collect children as have no doubt been labelled by other mothers as irresponsible, feckless idiot. I think I was already labelled thus anyway, as have been spotted in the past with a child in a pushchair with no shoes on in April. Plus my children's hair isn't always brushed very well.

So - who's unreasonable here?

OP posts:
MrsGuyOfGisbourne · 05/11/2008 14:18

I can understand why the mother whose DD accompanies yours did not want to assume responsibility for a 5 year old. It is one thing to allow our children to walt to school - mine are quite independent and sensible and Ds1 has been safely and confidently going alone across several roads since he was 7. But..... I am not happy for him to take responsibility for a smaller child. I was very unhappy when he was playing in the park, and the mother of one of DS2s friends who had a brattish toddler who wanted to join in, but she wanted to stay chatting to the other mums out of sight, casually asked DS1 to 'keep an eye on X' - not good to expect children to babysit smaller children imho.

nappyaddict · 11/11/2008 00:27

Everyone round here walks from about age 7, where there are no roads to cross 6 and i know someone who lives literally next door to the school and her 4 year old goes on his own.

gabygirl · 11/11/2008 06:49

MrsGuyOfGisbourne, if I'd thought about it a bit more (distracted by toddler's diarrheoa as children leaving house) I would have told my dd not to call for her friend. It really wasn't the case that I was asking my dd's friend to take responsibility for my middle one - it's just that she walks in anyway with my dd every day. Would also point out that it's only about 50 yards from this girl's front door to the school gate!

Anyway - have now cleared the air with both mums involved. Made my feelings very clear that a bit more support would have been helpful, rather than judgement. I have seen both these mums every day during term time for the past 6 years - our children went to nursery together, we live round the corner from each other and have baby sat each others children, and we have socialised with each other. I think what upset me most was being judged and criticised in front of my children, by people who have known me for a long time - who know that I'm a loving, responsible parent.

OP posts:
BouncingTurtle · 11/11/2008 06:57

You sound very sensible to me and you should congratulate yourself on raising independent, sensible children.
Glad you cleared the air with your friends, hope they apologised for their rudeness, especially for criticising you in front of your kids - that is so outrageous!

cornsilk · 11/11/2008 07:18

gabygirl they sound like a pair of numptys.

StewieGriffinsMom · 11/11/2008 08:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Totallyfloaty35 · 11/11/2008 09:22

tell them to mind their own,my dd who is nearly 11 has been getting train to school for past 4months,that caused masses of outrage at school gates i can tell you. But had no choice really was costing a fortune to drive her there ,we were always stuck in traffic,took over an hour to do a 9min train journey and when i suggested she change school to a closer one(we have just moved house) she got hysterical.
I walked to school from age 6,took my 4yr old brother when i was 8yrs old,everyone did it then.
As long as your child is sensible is ok and only you can know it,however have met some 14yr olds who shouldnt be allowed out without lead reins

missmama · 11/11/2008 09:45

With regard to your daughters friend, I have a 10yo and a 7yo that go everywhere together. If a friend of mine wants her 7yo to join in / hang round with them I have made it clear that neither of my children are responsible for him. The 10yo is accompanying his brother not looking after him and is not expected to look after anybody else.
I would not have expected this girl to have had any more responsibility than she would otherwise have had walking to school with your 1 daughter.

mooog · 11/11/2008 10:02

I agree with missmama. Why this stupid woman seems to think her kid should be responsible for your little one when he had his sister with him is pathetic. She sounds like a spiteful interfering bored old cow if you ask me. Hold your head up when picking kids up at school, you have done nothing wrong!

LadyThompson · 11/11/2008 10:19

I'm sorry for you. What a bunch of harpies. Slagging you off in front of your kids? Disgraceful. Stick to your guns. Explain yourself to the teacher if necessary.

Bubbaluv · 11/11/2008 10:29

So you called your friend and asked if they could come to hers and she take them into school. She says yes, but then yells at you when they turn up? Huh? Why? She already said yes!?

KatieDD · 11/11/2008 10:32

Jesus I was walking my sister 1/2 mile with 2 roads to cross at 6.
Some people just need to get a grip it's not like you were lying in bed is it (my mum was actually).
I would get a nice to mum to ask loudly how your DS is at the school to make it clear that was the cause of it all.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread