Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About thins (long one)

29 replies

mamamama2 · 17/08/2008 20:15

Okay, first off, please don't think this is a prank, an insult, or a troll; it's a serious and honest question, and I really want serious and honest opinions. I don't want to offend anyone, and I hope I don't.

Yeah, I'm new. Hi by the way.

Here's the situation.

When I was in my teens, I met a young woman (Vi) who rent on to become a very good friend of mine. Vi is part of a very strict Catholic family, and I was 17 at the time (she's American, so to her, age of consent is 18 and that's what she considers morally correct) so when she began developing feelings for me, it was problematic in several ways.

Now that I'm engaged to a lovely man (Chris) with a beautiful son (James) it's even more problematic.

See, in June 07 she tearfull admitted that she's still in love with me (an obsessive, unrequieted type of love that's driven her to depression and anorexia). I explained to her that I wouldn't leave Chris for her, which she had already known and accepted, and she went on her way, still thoroughly miserable and resigned. Chris, on the other hand, is perfectly fine with the idea of Vi and me having a relationship while maintaining one between he and I. It's not a pervy thing, wanting to see me with another woman, and he didn't know Vi's mental state, so it's not like he was being emotionally pressured or anything else; as far as he's aware to this day, she still just fancied me, and he knew I still had some feelings for her, but had already told her that there was no way I'd leave him for her. Put simply, he's absolutely okay with it. It's something even I struggle to understand, but he really is.

So Vi and I began a long distance relationship last autumn. In that time, Vi has made huge improvements medically, as have I (I also suffer depression and anxiety) as well as gaining a new zest for life (I'm a writer who never really got very far until just lately, and she was half way through a university degree she was going to just give up on) and mine and Chris's relationship has also improved.

Of course, I found out three months later that I was pregnant.

At first I didn't think about it, but now that Vi's finishing her degree and planning to move to England (not just for me or anything...she has family here and prefers it to America. She always planned to live in England after uni) it's something I'm having to consider. The arguement for homosexual's with children is one thing (i.e. will raising a child in a homosexual family 'teach' them to be homosexual themselves) but raising a child in a three-way relationship is another. The way I see is, James will have three parents who love him instead of just two, which can only be a good thing. However, I also understand that polygamy is still considered illegal and not something I can really encourage in my child.

However, it's not a simple case of just breaking up with Vi; she's got a fantastic career ahead of her, and wants nothing more than to move to England and look after me, Chris and James for the rest of our lives. Chris and I are in a terrible place, both financially, circumstancially and in our relationship at the moment, and without Vi we will be stuck in a small village living on council support for years. With the current economical situation in England, this is also something I loath instilling in my child, and the environment we're in is, in a word, dangerous. I'm scared to go to my window when someone's outside, let alone leave the house alone or think about letting James play outside when he's older. Vi can provide a much, much better life for him than either Chris or I can; even if I get the best job I can and he gets the best job he can, we probably won't make half of Vi's expected first-year income in our first five. And on top of that, with the amount of aid she gives mine and Chris's relationship, I don't think he and I would last very long without her there as the mediator.

So now you're probably thinking that the obvious solution is to split up with Chris. But if I do that, I'll be alone with my anxiety, depression and a baby in a nice dangerous place until next summer when Vi can come over, I'll be depriving Chris of his son and James of his dad, and most of the initial issues are still there; I know people raised in same sex relationships who have been fine with it, but what would you think if you grew up knowing that your mum left your dad two months after you were born for another woman? Chris and I are very good together, but the stressful situation we're in at the moment is making things hard for us both, and Ri's the only one who can reassure and calm us both. In 18 months, it'll be a completely differant story.

Anyways that's the problem. Again, I'm sorry if I offended anyone or if anyone thinks I'm just trolling; I promise I'm not. Thanks.

OP posts:
filthymindedvixen · 18/08/2008 13:09

well yes, but I see little monogamy fascism in any of the previous posts solidgoldbrass.

However, I also see someone who sees bringing a third person into her life as a ticket out of her unpleasant life. I think that's putting too much on Vi's shoulders persoanlly. Why is she the ''only one who can reassure and calm you both?''
This doesn't sound like a healthy relationship tbh.

Mamazon · 18/08/2008 13:09

ok. maybe i need to re read the post but i dont see what theproblem is?

You love both Chris and Vi, both chris and Vi are happy to allow you a relationship with the other.

whty can't you have a poly relationship? if its because you worry what society may think then dont.

most wouldn't even realise it was anything other than a couple with a lodger and those that do dont matter anyway.
so long as you are all happy with teh situation that is all that matters.

You son will be loved by 3 adults who care for him, that is a great thing. he will grow up knowing no different and will not view it as strange or weird at all.
he will grow up learning that love is not bound by gendre or religion or even societal pressures.

discuss what you want to do with all concerned and take things slowly. i would advise Vi to get her own place at first, and take things one step at a time...the way you would any relationship.
it will give you time and space to iron out any initial issues there are (jealousy, financial difficulties etc etc)

I wish you the very best of luck...and am slightly of you, ya lucky lukcy lady

Mamazon · 18/08/2008 13:09

ok. maybe i need to re read the post but i dont see what theproblem is?

You love both Chris and Vi, both chris and Vi are happy to allow you a relationship with the other.

whty can't you have a poly relationship? if its because you worry what society may think then dont.

most wouldn't even realise it was anything other than a couple with a lodger and those that do dont matter anyway.
so long as you are all happy with teh situation that is all that matters.

You son will be loved by 3 adults who care for him, that is a great thing. he will grow up knowing no different and will not view it as strange or weird at all.
he will grow up learning that love is not bound by gendre or religion or even societal pressures.

discuss what you want to do with all concerned and take things slowly. i would advise Vi to get her own place at first, and take things one step at a time...the way you would any relationship.
it will give you time and space to iron out any initial issues there are (jealousy, financial difficulties etc etc)

I wish you the very best of luck...and am slightly of you, ya lucky lukcy lady

Mamazon · 18/08/2008 13:09

ooops, so good i said it twice.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page