Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should schools be closed at 35°C?

770 replies

DancingThroughLife02 · Yesterday 08:39

Not really an AIBU but looking ahead at the forecast for next week and it’s looking like a scorcher.

I work in a secondary school in a science classroom (which seems to get extra hot during practicals) and we have no fans or AC or anything at all to keep the children cool. Open windows don’t seem to help much. The thermostat in the classroom got above 30°C in the afternoon.

The children need to have their water bottles filled at break times and lunch times only and are not allowed to fill them during lessons - which I disagree with as so many come to me saying that they didn’t get a chance to fill theirs up in the 20 minute lunch break.

Last week I had children saying they were dizzy and feeling sick, and they’re made to go outside during breaks. I’m also not sure that anything I taught them during the extra hot days actually stuck in anyway as they all seemed melted onto the desks.

I know there is a legal lower temperature limit for classrooms/workplaces but maybe with the increasing summer temperatures over the last few years we need to start considering investing in ACs as the heat in summer seems to be more prolonged than a couple hot days and in the meantime consider health and safety of the students (and teachers as even I was beginning to feel a bit dizzy).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Gettingaggy · Yesterday 12:43

JassyRadlett · Yesterday 12:42

It's so weird. There's a sizeable part of the population for whom comfort is a moral failing.

What are you doing to ‘fix the bullshit’?

Passingthrough123 · Yesterday 12:46

ProudCat · Yesterday 11:23

Schools are places of education, not childcare. If childcare is an issue in a heatwave, then employers need to release their staff (and it won't be all of them) under the conditions of reasonable adjustments. This is an employer / employee issue, not an education issue.

This ^. Schools are places of learning and teachers are not childminders.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 12:46

Gettingaggy · Yesterday 12:43

I’d love the fix the bullshit, but I’m a menopausal woman working full time in the NHS, 3 kids, one profoundly disabled, caring for my elderly mother, I get 4-5 hours sleep a night… I haven’t got the energy to fix bullshit. I can vote, but that’s all I can realistically do. If that’s down to my ‘British mentality’ then 🤷🏻‍♀️.
I think many of us would love to see schools have air con fitted in every classroom. We’d love to be able to take days off work to keep our kids at home whenever they needed to be at home. I haven’t got the time or the energy to lead the campaigns for those changes, but if anyone else would like to then I’ll happily get behind them.

What I am referring to isn't 'We'd love to see schools fitted with air con but that's not going to happen' it's 'WE PUT UP WITH WORSE DURING THE WAR SO YOU SHOULD JUST GET ON WITH IT' type of thing. Like survival is the only expectation that should be met and anything above that is unreasonable.

getwiththeprogram · Yesterday 12:48

People keep going on about 'the summer of '76. The very highest temp in the 'summer of '76' was 35 degrees recorded in just a couple of places. The average was 30/32 degrees across England

It's going to be 38/39 degrees on Wed and Thurs in many parts. Not 30/32. There's a huge difference in 6/8 degrees of heat.

Gettingaggy · Yesterday 12:50

ProudCat · Yesterday 11:23

Schools are places of education, not childcare. If childcare is an issue in a heatwave, then employers need to release their staff (and it won't be all of them) under the conditions of reasonable adjustments. This is an employer / employee issue, not an education issue.

And in theory I absolutely agree. This would of course involve everyone in the country accepting vastly reduced services in all areas during a heatwave (healthcare, power supply, food supply etc).

getwiththeprogram · Yesterday 12:52

Oriunda · Yesterday 11:22

Yes, they do, but adaptations are made. In Italy, most schools finish after first week of June, precisely to avoid the summer heat. They’ll reopen mid September.

We’re in France, and all state schools are closed this Monday, where we’re expecting 40 degrees plus. The rest of the week our children start earlier, and finish at lunchtime.

France is very sensible.

notnorman · Yesterday 12:52

DancingThroughLife02 · Yesterday 12:42

They can’t fill them with that water -absolutely not drinking water.

Nooo! Bacteria city! They’re deffo not run off the mains!! 🦠

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 12:52

Gettingaggy · Yesterday 12:50

And in theory I absolutely agree. This would of course involve everyone in the country accepting vastly reduced services in all areas during a heatwave (healthcare, power supply, food supply etc).

Why shouldn't secondaries close given that there's no childcare requirement?

PaperTyger · Yesterday 12:53

@noblegiraffe I agree as well on the fixing stuff.
There is a gernal malaise in our society I've seen it at work a problem with getting stuff sorted then the people with the will to do it are stuck in cycles of authority and can't but the people who have the power can't do it.
Utterly ridldicous

Passingthrough123 · Yesterday 12:54

GoneWithTHeWindJammers · Yesterday 11:59

It will be us oldies that will have to go - those who got through the summer of '76 without aircon or water bottles.

You cannot compare like for like though.

The highest temp recorded in the 1976 heatwave was just shy of 36 but that was one day and the highest it got over 15 consecutive days was 32. The UK heatwave record now stands at over 40 and the Met Office is saying we could have consecutive days of 40 this week under the heat dome.

Plus our infrastructure is denser than it was in '76 and the population has grown by 13 million, so we're more tightly packed in, especially in urban areas.

It's hotter and sweatier now in every sense!

PaperTyger · Yesterday 12:55

We need to look at why France can cope but we can't ?
We seem to be so rigid and lack originaltiy

DancingThroughLife02 · Yesterday 12:56

PaperTyger · Yesterday 12:55

We need to look at why France can cope but we can't ?
We seem to be so rigid and lack originaltiy

France has closed schools in the heat.

OP posts:
LewishamTeacher · Yesterday 12:57

Schools need to have the flexibility to do what they can to reduce the temperatures in their buildings in heatwaves but without investment, the options open to them are pretty much limited to relaxing uniform rules.

My previous school was a postwar, single story building. When it was sweltering a couple of summers ago I was able to cover the windows from the outside using sugar paper so the room didn't heat up quite so much as without. I brought in a fan from home each day but even then, it was so hot my classroom thermometer ran out of numbers!

scoobysnaxx · Yesterday 12:58

ExtraOnions · Yesterday 09:06

I don’t believe any any school has a 20 minute lunch break

We had hot weather in the 70s & 80s when I was at school, nobody had a water bottle - we just got on with it, everyone survived and nobody fainted.

Gold star for you.

PaperTyger · Yesterday 13:04

@DancingThroughLife02 yea so how do they cope with the same issues eg medical health workers ?

PaperTyger · Yesterday 13:06

@ExtraOnions au contraire.
My dp had lived in Oz for many years and came back and still spoke of the famous 76 heatwave .
As an ordeal and all the things that happened !

Peony1985 · Yesterday 13:09

cardibach · Yesterday 12:33

It wasn’t as hot. It went on for a long time, but the temperatures were lower.

But so far this year we’ve had 40 consecutive days of a rain and low temperatures in spring.

We ‘ve literally only had one hot week which was half term but temperatures dropped the week after and last week was just ok.
Next week might be boiling but unless it carries on for a while it’s no even close to 76.

And in 76 there wasn’t the plastic bottles of water and drinks that we have everywhere, ice cream was still a block and wafers in the supermarkets and no air con anywhere.

JassyRadlett · Yesterday 13:09

Gettingaggy · Yesterday 12:43

What are you doing to ‘fix the bullshit’?

Why are you quoting something I've not said at me?

Joliefolie · Yesterday 13:10

The local schools here have the windows open during the night, to be closed at 8am. Can you stick foil on the windows?

Spottyvases · Yesterday 13:10

ExtraOnions · Yesterday 09:06

I don’t believe any any school has a 20 minute lunch break

We had hot weather in the 70s & 80s when I was at school, nobody had a water bottle - we just got on with it, everyone survived and nobody fainted.

Righto

If that is what you're saying, it must all be true 🙄

Hot weather in the 70s and 80s did not exceed 35 degrees C - ever.

Suirren · Yesterday 13:11

A ‘side effect’ of school is childcare. So if I have to take two days off to look after my kids, I have to cancel two days’ of clinics for patients (no ac there either) and they will be waiting another six months. That just cannot happen.

Fitting ac everywhere is going to be impossible financially for schools and the government won’t pay. We need pragmatic solutions asap.

I would cancel sports days.
Allow kids to wear t shirts and shorts if they want.
Try and see if the school could buy cheap water misters for every class and not let the kids leave the classroom without returning them after every lesson.
The government should be pressurised to at least pay for proper blackout blinds and fans for schools.
A longer term strategy is then needed.

bumptybum · Yesterday 13:14

ShetlandishMum · Yesterday 08:48

No. Of course not.

You do realise don’t you that in those conditions the room would likely be well over 40°
if the room faced the sun it would easily reach 50°

I think you are being ridiculous.

not only would teachers struggle to be in 45-50° heat for HOURS but no real learning would take place.
and those temperatures are not safe

bumptybum · Yesterday 13:16

Cooshawn · Yesterday 08:52

Children go to schools in hot climates (without air conditioning) all over the world.

Schools aren't going to be all retrofitted with air con, but should have blinds and fans easily enough. And they should be providing shade, be that outside or inside.

The countries you speak of have buildings that are built taking those temperatures into account

added to which humans have an incredible ability to adapt to their climate. The point is, we are not used to this climate And our climate changes dramatically throughout the year

The countries are you’re speaking about don’t swing dramatically cold so their bodies have a different set point

In this country, depend depending on the direction the room phases and that room will be 45 to 50°

The students won’t learn anything in my teacher should be in that temperature for hours a day

It’s not safe

MagicThanks · Yesterday 13:16

I’ve just had a thought - I wonder how we’re going to feed them. I doubt it’ll be safe to have industrial ovens on Tues - Thurs when it’s due to be 40 degrees. It’ll have to be cold sandwiches only I guess.

Swipe left for the next trending thread