Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be surprised there is no proper film about the plague?

113 replies

AliceNotInChains · 28/05/2026 21:13

Would love to see a proper well done movie about the plague - AIBU to be suprised that it hasn’t been done?? Titanic style

OP posts:
Foraor · 28/05/2026 23:54

Twisterlollies · 28/05/2026 23:48

What would the story arc be? There were no big medical breakthroughs, there was no vaccine or uplifting end to it. Just an awful lot of people dying a hideous death after a life of drinking unsterilised water, living with cattle and giving birth in fields.

Exactly. The very popular novel I’ve sometimes been surprised hasn’t ever (to my knowledge) been filmed, Connie Willis’s The Doomsday Book (timetravelling history student is accidentally sent to the Black Death and can’t be recalled because there’s a contemporary pandemic) hasn’t been filmed in part because the latter part of the Black Death timeline is so horrifying as the time-traveller, who is immune, nurses all the characters we’ve got to know as they die horribly.

Isittimeformynapyet · 28/05/2026 23:59

Aintgointogoa · 28/05/2026 23:46

Hammett (the movie) was plague adjacent I believe ....as far as I understand it, great swathes of the great and the good plus the monarch and court debunked to their country estates from London in the summer as the disease hadn't run it's course but wasn't quite plague pit levels. Also Wolf Hall (Henry VIII & Thomas Cromwell) has this narrative. Not particularly keen to revisit personally 🤧

the monarch and court debunked to their country estates

decamped

Twisterlollies · 28/05/2026 23:59

Covid the Movie would be so much easier script wise.

Romance: Matt Hancock and Gina Thingy
Plot twist: Dominic Cummings
Light humour: Boris Johnson

Settings:
Houses of Parliament
Barnard Castle
Matt Hancock’s love nest

Music:
Dancing Queen
Chimes of BBC News at 6

MyAutumnCrow · Yesterday 00:11

FieryMexicanClive · 28/05/2026 23:44

Yanbu they should get Julia Roberts in. Eat, Plague, Love.

She’s got a whole catalogue ahead of her.

Septic Pizza
Seeping with the Enemy
Dying Young

InterestedDad37 · Yesterday 00:16

I'm imagining a Busby Berkeley-style musical, called "Bring Out Your Dead" 😀 🧟 💃 🕺 🦠 🐀 🎶

AllTheChaos · Yesterday 00:22

Foraor · 28/05/2026 23:54

Exactly. The very popular novel I’ve sometimes been surprised hasn’t ever (to my knowledge) been filmed, Connie Willis’s The Doomsday Book (timetravelling history student is accidentally sent to the Black Death and can’t be recalled because there’s a contemporary pandemic) hasn’t been filmed in part because the latter part of the Black Death timeline is so horrifying as the time-traveller, who is immune, nurses all the characters we’ve got to know as they die horribly.

Is that the one where she can’t speak the local language at first as the translation implant has gone wrong? With the priest who sort of falls in love with her, helps care for the sick then dies himswlf? If so thank you - I’ve been trying to remember the name of the book for ages without success!

aurpod1980 · Yesterday 00:26

Hamnet

TowerRaven · Yesterday 00:30

Restoration, 1995 dir. Michael Hoffman and starring Robert Downey Jr.
Plague and Great Fire! I remember it being pretty naff.

ScullyD · Yesterday 01:04

I think some kind of Robert Eggers tale could for this. I think he’s the only one that could pull it off!

Newname26 · Yesterday 01:11

Nopenott0day · 28/05/2026 22:18

There's enough bad historical "knowledge" about "the plague" (everyone usually means the one of the 14th c, when really there was a few), such as bird masks (which didn't appear til mid 17thc) that I'm not sure Hollywood could possibly make it worse.

Yes and for some reason I thought it only affected the densely populated London

It was a passing comment by a historian at Dunfermline Abbey that told me different, that's a mass grave from the plague of x date and the one over there is y date. 😳

MaySheWillStay · Yesterday 01:13

LegallyBlondish · 28/05/2026 21:42

The Roses of Eyam - a 1970s adaptation of a play based around true facts. I remember watching it as a child. I did a history degree back in the olden days & I find this era, and this particular story, to be fascinating.

When Covid hit, the English/Drama teacher at the learning centre I TA’d at did this with a group online.

Well done, Teresa! (We’ve both retired now)

canuckup · Yesterday 02:10

There isn't one about the Pendle witch trials either

viques · Yesterday 02:14

The Journal of the Plague Year.

All the stats could be presented as text on the screen. Be just like reading the book, oh, hold on a minute , bit of a flaw in the argument there, back in a while……

viques · Yesterday 02:16

canuckup · Yesterday 02:10

There isn't one about the Pendle witch trials either

The Crucible. Though names might have been changed to protect the innocent. And a slight location variance as well, but that’s the wonder of cinema, you can do things to history that make historians go into a corner and gibber. Think Braveheart.

cariadlet · Yesterday 06:37

viques · Yesterday 02:16

The Crucible. Though names might have been changed to protect the innocent. And a slight location variance as well, but that’s the wonder of cinema, you can do things to history that make historians go into a corner and gibber. Think Braveheart.

There were a lot of witch trials.

The Crucible was based on the Salem Witch trials, not the Pendle ones. Arthur Miller didn't change the names of the real life protagonists although he did change some of the ages and relationships. From memory, he made one of the girls older to allow for a relationship between her and John Proctor.

AliceNotInChains · Yesterday 06:37

canuckup · Yesterday 02:10

There isn't one about the Pendle witch trials either

That’s another one that would make a great film!

OP posts:
5128gap · Yesterday 06:56

fandjango · 28/05/2026 23:36

This is me too. I was petrified of contracting the plague from the dirty parts of the school playground at 6. Drove my parents mad as was constantly washing!

We had to do this play about Eyam. I remember having to say "Doesn't the air smell sweet tonight?" I became obsessed with whether I could smell anything sweet.

Thiswasanescapeplan · Yesterday 07:11

MyAutumnCrow · Yesterday 00:11

She’s got a whole catalogue ahead of her.

Septic Pizza
Seeping with the Enemy
Dying Young

Runaway from The Bride

Thiswasanescapeplan · Yesterday 07:16

AliceNotInChains · Yesterday 06:37

That’s another one that would make a great film!

@AliceNotInChains according to @Notmyreality you don't "really mean it" when you asked about plague films 😭

LottieMary · Yesterday 07:19

LegallyBlondish · 28/05/2026 21:42

The Roses of Eyam - a 1970s adaptation of a play based around true facts. I remember watching it as a child. I did a history degree back in the olden days & I find this era, and this particular story, to be fascinating.

I actually love this play
performed it at school and as a teacher occasionally bring it out when I have a spare week and we all do a read through. They get weirdly into wondering who will die next (there’s about 30 roles!) haven’t done it post Covid though….

CaptainMyCaptain · Yesterday 07:38

CaragianettE · 28/05/2026 21:37

I’m not sure how you would do a big sweeping romantic drama about the plague? Titanic really lent itself to spectacle, all the glamour and luxury then the spectacle and drama of the iceberg collision. Wasn’t the plague mostly people having to stay barricaded in their houses so they wouldn’t die in extremely horrible ways? I can see a horror movie being made about it, I’m not really seeing ‘Titanic’? Where would the romance come in?

The romance:
Lost love of Rowland Torre and Emmott Sydall | Stoney Middleton Heritage https://share.google/2ZeS4K7atEkgERfya

Lost love of Rowland Torre and Emmott Sydall | Stoney Middleton Heritage

A story of heartbreak concerning Emmott Sydall and Rowland Torre, separated from one another when the village of Eyam quarantined itself during an outbreak of the Plague, meeting daily at a distance they would shout to eachother until one day when all...

https://smhccg.org/folklore-legends/lost-love-of-rowland-torre-and-emmott-sydall/

Daisydoesnt · Yesterday 07:51

I’m surprised the very readable “Turn of Midnight” by Minette Walters hasn’t been mentioned yet. It’s set in Dorset in a moated village which barricades itself in: the bubonic plague is thought to have landed in medieval England at Melcombe Regis, near Weymouth. It really brought to life for me what it might have been like as the plague ravaged the countryside, villages, people.

It doesn’t sound very promising but it’s a really interesting and entertaining read!!

Pearshapedpear · Yesterday 07:54

Thiswasanescapeplan · 28/05/2026 21:33

Plague, Actually 😷

Genius @Thiswasanescapeplan

Foraor · Yesterday 08:57

AllTheChaos · Yesterday 00:22

Is that the one where she can’t speak the local language at first as the translation implant has gone wrong? With the priest who sort of falls in love with her, helps care for the sick then dies himswlf? If so thank you - I’ve been trying to remember the name of the book for ages without success!

Yes, that’s the one, @AllTheChaos. It’s not the translation implant that’s gone wrong, just that the contemporary scholars simply didn’t know enough about the language as it was used then to programme it, until it picked up more material once Kivrin actually arrived (because the whole period had been barred for time travel as too dangerous.) And yes, sweet Father Roch falls for her but also thinks she’s a saint sent by god to help them.

viques · Yesterday 10:18

cariadlet · Yesterday 06:37

There were a lot of witch trials.

The Crucible was based on the Salem Witch trials, not the Pendle ones. Arthur Miller didn't change the names of the real life protagonists although he did change some of the ages and relationships. From memory, he made one of the girls older to allow for a relationship between her and John Proctor.

I stand corrected. 😷