Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want more space from family after having my baby

24 replies

ByMintBear · 24/05/2026 11:23

AIBU to want everyone to back off a bit?

I’m 40 and had my first baby just under 2 weeks ago. DH is 42. We absolutely adore our little boy and honestly becoming his mum has been the best thing ever.

We are also very lucky to have a really good support system and lots of family wanting to help. I do appreciate that.

But if I’m honest I’m starting to feel overwhelmed by everyone’s opinions and constant presence.

Even during pregnancy people were weirdly judgmental about my age. I wanted a water birth and several people who were not doctors, midwives or healthcare professionals told me I was “too old” and should just do a c section. I am actually a doctor myself and was perfectly capable of making informed decisions about my own pregnancy and birth with guidance from other medical professionals. Everything went well and baby arrived safely.

Now he’s here it feels like every choice we make gets commented on.

For example we are using mostly cloth nappies because we wanted less waste. Yes it’s more work but DH is very hands on and does most of the laundry anyway. Apparently this is now also wrong and I’ve had endless comments about how disposable nappies are easier and I’ll “give up eventually”.

It honestly feels at times like people are just waiting for me to fail so they can say “told you so”. The cloth nappies are just one example. Apparently because I’m a first time mum at 40 I’m supposed to give up on anything remotely inconvenient and just do everything the easiest possible way.

I really don’t understand what is so terrible about at least trying to be less wasteful. If it ends up not working for us long term then fine, we’ll adapt, but I don’t see why people seem so invested in proving that I can’t do it.

DH’s mum has also been staying with us for over a week and while I know she means well, I’m really struggling with how intense she is being. She constantly wants to hold the baby, hovers when I’m feeding him, and comments on pretty much everything I do. If he cries she immediately swoops in. I feel like I’m being treated like a clueless teenager instead of a grown woman who is perfectly capable of caring for her own child.

What’s making me feel worse is that my own mum has actually been really helpful. She comes over, helps, doesn’t overstay, and then leaves us to it. She lets me take the lead because he is my son. I don’t feel judged or watched with her.

With MIL I constantly feel like she’s hovering waiting for me to make some sort of mistake so she can step in or prove she knows better.

Maybe I’m just being ungrateful because I know she loves him and wants to help. I also know there are a lot of emotions flying around at the moment.

But honestly I just want some quiet time with my husband and baby without feeling observed in my own home. I like support but do not like the constant ‘that’s now what you should do’ MIL said ‘I’ve had 4 kids this is your first trust me I know slightly more than you’

AIBU?

OP posts:
Mischance · 24/05/2026 11:27

Time for MIL to go home! Tell her ... now!

Fluffybuns88 · 24/05/2026 11:30

Unfortunately this is life with young children, everyone likes to comment from family member to random people in the street.
It tends to ease off over time or at least you notice it less as your confidence grows, but it will be a constant until your child is old enough, then it will change to people giving them advice instead of you.

Pro tip, nod and agree and carry on as you are.

Thelonelyshrew · 24/05/2026 11:31

Agree with pp. she needs to leave.

Stoicandhappy · 24/05/2026 11:32

Time for MIL to go home

TeaPot496 · 24/05/2026 11:33

Fuckers! Get your DH to tell her to leave..

olivielilly · 24/05/2026 11:34

For some reason, when you have a baby, everyone has an opinion on everything. It’s odd and annoying. It’s not just you.

Family need to let you take the lead, your baby wants you, his mum right now.

Take care, it’s an emotional time.

thornbury · 24/05/2026 11:36

I used cloth nappies with DD, she's 26 now! No bother at all, I wished I had used them with my firstborn.

Congratulations on your new arrival 😀

sesquipedalian · 24/05/2026 11:39

“DH’s mum has also been staying with us for over a week ”

WAY too long when you have such a young baby - I think I might have killed my MIl had she stayed for so long when the baby was so young. I completely understand where you’re coming from with unwanted comments - I can remember on one occasion during dinner, when MIL had said once too often that babies cry “ for exercise” taking my DS and disappearing upstairs with him before I landed my dinner in her head! (DS is now 40.) OP, it’s your baby, and din’t let anyone try to belittle you or question your views. Crack on with cloth nappies; take your baby to your bedroom to escape MIL “hovering” during feeding, and get your DH to tell her that you don’t like her swooping in and taking the baby every time he cries. It sounds to me as though it’s way past time for MIL to go home - and your DH needs to become much better at advocating for you, and keeping his DM at bay.

aloris · 24/05/2026 11:40

Tell her to go away. This is YOUR baby. She had her turn when she had her own.

ByMintBear · 24/05/2026 11:41

Stoicandhappy · 24/05/2026 11:32

Time for MIL to go home

I 100% agree I just feel guilty because people would kill to have this sort of support.
She has been helping out a lot when she’s not judging, she’s been doing the food shop, running errands for DH and I do we can both spend time with our son together etc.

I think I will speak to DH and decide it’s time for to go home. He’s been feeling judged too but we both don’t want to hurt her feelings. She’s retired and not much else to to do her and FIL just go on lots of holidays so when they’re back in England they have nothing to do. Our son is the youngest grandchild, all the others are in secondary school so aren’t around as much.

OP posts:
IndigoBluey · 24/05/2026 11:44

Was MIL moving in straight from the birth agreed beforehand? This seems intrusive and doesn’t sound like you are getting any personal time with your newborn. How long is her stay planned for? I agree ☝️ DH needs to ask her to head back to her own house.

hahabahbag · 24/05/2026 11:45

Time for mil to go home and visit maybe twice a week for an hour or two if feasible (no idea how far she lives) if not every other week staying one night perhaps.

cloth nappies are easy, ignore the naysayers, they just don’t realise that it’s not extra work really, the work is done by your washing machine! I had 24 nappies (prefolds) plus 4 wraps and each size which did both kids including a period when they were both in nappies, you just wash more frequently then. Saved a fortune and once I was done I sold mine on for almost what I paid for them!

youalright · 24/05/2026 11:50

Who the hell invited her to move in for a week i never understand people who want parents to move in when they've had a baby that sounds like absolutely hell

GinaandGin · 24/05/2026 11:53

ByMintBear · 24/05/2026 11:41

I 100% agree I just feel guilty because people would kill to have this sort of support.
She has been helping out a lot when she’s not judging, she’s been doing the food shop, running errands for DH and I do we can both spend time with our son together etc.

I think I will speak to DH and decide it’s time for to go home. He’s been feeling judged too but we both don’t want to hurt her feelings. She’s retired and not much else to to do her and FIL just go on lots of holidays so when they’re back in England they have nothing to do. Our son is the youngest grandchild, all the others are in secondary school so aren’t around as much.

Sod her feelings
She is OK with hurting your feelings
So too bad
Get here out. Now.

KnittyKnotty · 24/05/2026 11:56

MIL has outstayed her welcome. I would be telling DH to take her home otherwise you'll be heading off to a hotel for a few nights.

Don't worry too much about the advice, that just happens, people love to think back to when they had their babies.

And as for the nappies, I couldn't be bothered with that but good luck with it.

Avie29 · 24/05/2026 12:02

Agree with PPs time for MIL to go home.
Its not support if her presence is causing you stress -its actually the opposite.
I didn’t have much support from family/friends when i had my children and it was great, you can just be in your bubble with baby and DH, i know some people like/need the extra support but for me i liked it to be just me, OH and new baby.

Endofyear · 24/05/2026 14:10

Welcome to Motherhood! You will find that the world and his wife will have an opinion on how you're looking after your baby and this will continue throughout his life! You just have to develop a thick skin, shrug it off & learn to say 'we all do things differently and that's ok' or just 'thanks for your input'! You don't have to argue the toss with them or justify your own choices and decisions - you can just smile and inwardly roll your eyes!

Tell MIL it's been lovely but it's time for her to go home now, you want time together as a little family. That's perfectly reasonable and if she gets offended, that's her choice.

Dozer · 24/05/2026 14:15

Congratulations on your baby!

DH should politely ask MIL to go home.

Ignore unsolicited comments / advice - standard but annoying!

lochmaree · 24/05/2026 15:05

Some people are weird about cloth nappies. I had lots of comments that we'd give up, or they'd get nappy rash etc. Used cloth for all 3 kids, and disposable when convenient. My MIL even sends us literally 100s of disposable nappies so that we don't use cloth, I still use cloth 🤣 (it's a control thing from her)

Sounds like it's time for MIL to go.

westcott · 24/05/2026 15:08

When is she supposed to be going home? What is the plan?

Honeybee111 · 24/05/2026 15:58

Firstly, congratulations on your new little boy.
Nothing is as tiring as friends and family who help when you’re new parents.
I’m sure everyone means well but having your MIL in the house for over a week would tip most new parents over the edge.
You’re doing what’s right by you and your baby, no need for anyone to hover over you.

Walk tall, you’re amazing parents, don’t let anyone make you feel any different.
Be firm and keep visitors away if you want time to yourselves.

Unfortunately, people will always spout their options, whether they’re being asked or not…

TomatoSandwiches · 24/05/2026 16:05

The universal experince of a FTM, it's actually dispicable, even worse that women do it to them and try to ride roughshod over them during such a really vulnerable time, I don't get the psychology of it and I know it's not everyone but still..

She needs to go home, DH can deal with telling her, make sure he gets her a nice gift in thanks to soften the blow but enough now.

AnneElliott · 24/05/2026 17:26

You need to cultivate smile and nod and then carry on exactly as you were before. It’s probably going to annoy you even more being a Dr, but the very worst for infantilising mums are healthcare professionals. So many times I wanted to scream that I’m actually a clever woman with a professional job and lots of responsibility so why are you treating me like I’m some sort of idiot?
Deffo get MIL to go home - you need to get into your own routine and rhythm.

Lemonymint · 24/05/2026 17:41

Maybe she just wants to feel involved. I mean you're a doctor so you must know something about babies ie more than her. I just wanted my mother, who was lovely and who always deferred to me about the baby, to go home so my husband and I could actually parent so I understand how you feel. My actual MIL had no interest in her grandchildren - I can't remember her ever even picking up either of my children as babies or indeed ever touching them so it could be much worse.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread