Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel undermined by my mum's constant unsolicited advice?

31 replies

mullingitallover43 · 10/05/2026 14:20

My mum has a tendency to give me unsolicited advice / suggestions on how I should run my life.

Here's an example; we have a family wedding next weekend and my son is in the middle of GCSEs. Mum just called me to ask if he has any GCSEs on the Monday morning after the wedding. So I tell her again, yes, he does. She tells me "Oh, well you don't have to stay until the end of the wedding then, you can leave early and get him home."

I've discussed this with my husband already and we had already decided to do that as a couple, without her weighing in.

Another example. I recently had a minor surgery. She told me "I really want you to get a cleaner while you're recovering," and and that she would pay for it. A kind gesture, seemingly, but something I'd prefer to discuss with my husband and pay for ourselves.

For context I am 44, married, have a responsible and successful career. She did not have a career herself, and was a homemaker.

I know she thinks she's being helpful and caring, and that some might think I'm being ungrateful or cold, but I find it chips away at me and feels disempowering.

If you're reading this thinking why don't you just ask her to stop...on the couple of times that I have done that, she's been offended. I once asked her to not advise me on how much water to put in a vase of flowers, and she turned red and stormed out of my house in a huff.

This is a very entrenched dynamic that I've probably enabled for years. For example, she used to often answer for me when I was a kid. Then when I had my sons, she was very present and hands on involved with raising them, which was often super helpful but also overbearing at times. Whenever she's at my house, she'll get started with cleaning, or gardening, and always arrives with bags full of stuff for the house and for the boys.

YABU - Many of us would love the help of a caring mother, take the good from it and be grateful she cares in her way.

YANBU - This is overbearing behaviour and you need to set better boundaries with her.

OP posts:
mummypigoink · 10/05/2026 18:14

I completely get this. Individually they might be innocuous examples but over a lifetime it becomes just the next bit of criticism and the next thing to make you less.

Id say try to set boundaries, but I know mine ignores any boundaries.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 10/05/2026 18:15

Is it perhaps down to phrasing?

I recently explained to a couple of my adult kids that when I say 'you should paint this room green!' or 'you should get Hello Fresh meals,' I am not meaning that is is what you MUST do, I am using 'should' to mean 'could/this is a possibility/this is what I would do if I were in your place'. They were hearing 'you should...' as 'I think you must...' Once I explained that it wasn't an order or three line whip, it was just an opinion, they stopped being annoyed by me saying it. And I, on the other hand, realised how annoying I was being when I get over enthusiastic about things!

BlissfullyBoring · 10/05/2026 23:34

@mullingitallover43 I wouldn’t be taking my DS to a wedding the day before his GCSEs.

lechatdhenri · 11/05/2026 08:21

So the op’s had her mum answering for her as a kid, is constantly telling her how to do everything, feels the need to even tell her how much water to put in a vase, and you all think that’s fine and dandy and she’s being ungrateful? I find mumsnet a strange place sometimes.
Yes, it may be coming from a place of love, but if you can’t even politely ask your mum not to patronise you about something tiny without her walking out in a huff, then that’s not a very healthy dynamic is it? It starts to sound more like it also coming from a place of anxiety and control.

LovelyAnd · 11/05/2026 08:25

If you haven’t asked her to stop, or you see her being offended when you have as a reason never to do it again, YABU.

Cleo65 · 11/05/2026 08:31

Gosh - go no contact immediately, must be very traumatic having a Mum who cares about you & your children so much.....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread