Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just say F it and move to Cornwall and homeschool my Dc

249 replies

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 20:15

Or find a lovely little village school and spend our days living a slow, traditional life

It’s my dream

Has anyone got this, am I being realistic?

OP posts:
Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:53

ToffeeCrabApple · Yesterday 21:43

State schools are funded per pupil and the model assumes classes of 30 or so. You don't magically get smaller classes without losing funding so for example you might get 25 in a class but you'll lose the TA. If classes get too small to manage financially they will tend to merge year groups which isn't always ideal.

Small villages in Cornwall tend to be poor with no jobs. Its a hell of a long way to any city of a meaningful size - Bristol or Southampton are probably the closest and not really commutable from Cornwall. Better off people are likely to be concentrated in public sector - medical/teaching/council type jobs.

Not sure what "traditional lifestyle" means.

If you want an area where money will go further and you might perhaps afford a SAHP for example, your best bet is to look at parts of the uk with the most affordable housing relative to local wages, but not too far from cities with jobs. The midlands for example still has quite a few less expensive areas but jobs in Birmingham & people do commute down to London. Then there are more options up North if you look at commuting to places like Manchester or Leeds for work.

I don’t want to live in Birmingham or the Midlands 😔

OP posts:
hamsterchump · Yesterday 21:54

funnyfoursome · Yesterday 21:49

There won't be less children per class just because it's Cornwall!! You'll have to be prepared to drive much further, e.g. to Truro or Plymouth if you want chain shops, restauraunts etc.

This is true sort of but does anyone really want chain shops and restaurants that much? Have none of you heard of online shopping? Cornwall does have the internet and delivery vans now. I didn't really think people went shopping in person all that much any more, I get everything on Vinted now.

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:55

TotHappy · Yesterday 21:44

I'm sorry op but my kids go to a small village school in Cornwall (because I am Cornish) and the classes are overflowing. They don't play out much either and are always cutting PE. No money. No money down here.

But is your life doable? Does the environment & lifestyle make up for it?

OP posts:
Kusanajoy · Yesterday 21:55

I regret moving back for "better" childhoods. The children want to be closer to good museums. And events.

Wanted to go in the sea at the weekend but there was sewage and tampons floating about. We ended up just going home.

Sad times tbh!

WelshRabBite · Yesterday 21:56

UnhappyHobbit · Yesterday 21:05

Isn’t winter grim every where in the uk?! It would be very strange for anyone to assume Cornwall would be different.

If you’ve spent any time in Cornwall you’ll know it practically has its own climate.

As a comparison, today my iPhone says that London is going to be dry for the next week and top temp of 23 on Friday. Cornwall prediction is 5 days of rain and top temp 18 degrees.

When your mates are posting pics of sunbathing in their gardens and you’re in the pissing rain, again, you notice the difference 🤷‍♀️

LoveofSevenDolls · Yesterday 21:56

Both went away to university and stayed working in their university towns - so 200-300 miles. In all honesty I wouldn't do it again - I would have moved within Yorkshire. For other family reasons we have to stay - which is fine (just fine) - I miss home, never really felt settled.

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:56

Ophy83 · Yesterday 21:47

Last time we were in Perranporth the local kids were doing PE lessons on the beach. It did look fun. But I think it would be expensive to live there. Not just cost of property but there are very few "normal" shops- it's all surf shops, pottery/art/knitwear artisanal shops and bakeries that charge £11 for a crab sandwich. Also the locals aren't known for being welcoming to newcomers.

You have Truro for shops tho? and Exeter a bit further out?

OP posts:
Kusanajoy · Yesterday 21:57

hamsterchump · Yesterday 21:54

This is true sort of but does anyone really want chain shops and restaurants that much? Have none of you heard of online shopping? Cornwall does have the internet and delivery vans now. I didn't really think people went shopping in person all that much any more, I get everything on Vinted now.

You are right. But I have to admit my signal is so bad around Newquay and Truro - my iPhones battery says the most drain on it is "poor mobile coverage"

WhereTheHellAreMyGlasses · Yesterday 21:57

TotHappy · Yesterday 21:44

I'm sorry op but my kids go to a small village school in Cornwall (because I am Cornish) and the classes are overflowing. They don't play out much either and are always cutting PE. No money. No money down here.

People see the cost of houses in Cornwall and forget that the county was in receipt of EU Objective One funding, making it one of the most deprived areas in the whole of the EU. As a whole it is very poor and with little economic resilience.

An economy based on tourism leaves it with seasonal, low paid jobs and poor prospects for young people. There’s one hospital with an A&E. But due to the price of houses you’ll struggle to support a family on one income to free you up to homeschool.

Unless you plan to use the beach for all your leisure, you should probably look for another area to help your children to thrive.

Kusanajoy · Yesterday 21:58

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:56

You have Truro for shops tho? and Exeter a bit further out?

Truro shops? Pound shops, over priced charity shops, betting shops and a Primark?

How exciting!

🤣

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:59

Kusanajoy · Yesterday 21:48

Cornish here. It's great for young kids. But mine are now at secondary and it's pretty shit. Similar to how it was for me in the 90s and 00s.

We're going to move away as soon as the youngest leaves secondary.

I actually found some used needles recently. Drugs are quite an issue here (as they were in the 00s too!!)

I avoid Perranporth. It's too overwhelming for me 😂

Overwhelming in Perranporth, how? Genuinely interested from people who live there

Teen life like in the 90’s/2000’s sounds great to me! Drugs so much…but i’m from the North originally and drugs were everywhere

OP posts:
hamsterchump · Yesterday 22:01

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:53

I don’t want to live in Birmingham or the Midlands 😔

Can you afford to live in Cornwall? Do your jobs exist down here or can you work remotely? What are your housing requirements and budget? 3 bed terraced houses in the most affordable areas of Newquay start at about £230k, here's a pretty nice looking example in St Columb Minor: https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/173967950#/?channel=RES_BUY

Check out this 3 bedroom terraced house for sale on Rightmove

3 bedroom terraced house for sale in Calshot Close, St Columb Minor, TR7 for £230,000. Marketed by Newquay Property Centre, Newquay

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/173967950#/?channel=RES_BUY

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Yesterday 22:01

Does it have to be Cornwall? There are lots of places in the UK with lots of outside space and will be better salaries to house prices ration than Cornwall.

Kusanajoy · Yesterday 22:02

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:59

Overwhelming in Perranporth, how? Genuinely interested from people who live there

Teen life like in the 90’s/2000’s sounds great to me! Drugs so much…but i’m from the North originally and drugs were everywhere

A few summers ago Perranporth needed police to control overcrowding. There were approx 8000 people on the beach!

WallaceinAnderland · Yesterday 22:02

If you already have family in Cornwall OP then surely you already know what it's like?

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 22:02

hamsterchump · Yesterday 21:54

This is true sort of but does anyone really want chain shops and restaurants that much? Have none of you heard of online shopping? Cornwall does have the internet and delivery vans now. I didn't really think people went shopping in person all that much any more, I get everything on Vinted now.

Yes exactly, i’m not hugely fussed about clothes shops and there’s plenty of cafes and beach restaurants from what Ive seen

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · Yesterday 22:04

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 22:02

Yes exactly, i’m not hugely fussed about clothes shops and there’s plenty of cafes and beach restaurants from what Ive seen

Overrun in the summer, closed in winter.

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 22:04

Kusanajoy · Yesterday 21:55

I regret moving back for "better" childhoods. The children want to be closer to good museums. And events.

Wanted to go in the sea at the weekend but there was sewage and tampons floating about. We ended up just going home.

Sad times tbh!

Tampons in the sea in Cornwall?!

OP posts:
Terfedout · Yesterday 22:04

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:16

It would be Newquay/Perranporth area

Don't do it. Overcrowded in summer. Dead in winter and the deprivation becomes more visible. Very little all year round work. Speaking as someone who used to live there and moved away!

Falmouth has a bit more going for it and a bit more all year round stuff going on, but year round work is still a big issue. Truro is actually OK, most parts anyway. But still not all that much going on.

I would not move back to Cornwall unless retired, even though I absolutely love it and my family also still live there.

midnights92 · Yesterday 22:05

It's Cornwall, not Timbuktu so obviously a lot of things wouldn't be that different. But you sound a bit naive about the reality of moving to some of the countries most deprived and isolated areas. It's a lovely place to visit as a tourist, but living there means housing is a nightmare because almost everything is a second home or Airbnb, lots of the economy is summer time only, there is a lot of poverty and it can be very isolating if you're not a local. Public transport is almost non existent so you might find your children are far more isolated growing up than they would be in a more central town as they can walk to friends and get the bus to town. I lived on the border growing up and was always very glad not to be one of my friends driving and hour to school each way and never being able to do anything at the weekends because there was one bus a day and it didn't work. Unemployment is also very high and salaries are low.

LoveofSevenDolls · Yesterday 22:06

@Typingonkeyboard

Most of the kids take drugs because there is nothing to do, they don't have much money and likely don't have a job and can't see a way of that changing. Lots of poverty in Cornwall - drugs, alcohol, poor mental health.

RafaFan · Yesterday 22:06

Waterwaterwaterwaterwatercycle · Yesterday 20:20

It is a lovely dream! Whether it is realistic depends on your career, finances, whether you have a partner etc.

More info needed

And the OP's aptitude for homeschooling. That certainly is not a good fit for everyone, and lots of people don't know that until they try it. Somebody I know thought it would solve all her problems, found she was not at all suited to it, sank into a deep depression, and discovered the whole process had seriously messed her kids up too, to the point where they were too anxious to go back to conventional schooling.

AngelinaFibres · Yesterday 22:06

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 21:02

Just less kids per class, outside space & fresh air, tight knit, safe community…

The tricky thing with fewer children per class is. . ..
If your child doesn't like the teacher/ teacher doesn't like the child you are stuck with each other for more than the usual 1 year stint ( small schools often group the infants in one single class or Years 1 and 2 together. Years 3 and 4 and years 5 and 6 also often grouped together. So 2 years with the same teacher .
Fewer opportunities for friendships. Potentially no one suitable that they gel with

Kusanajoy · Yesterday 22:06

Typingonkeyboard · Yesterday 22:04

Tampons in the sea in Cornwall?!

Yes, very common! Lots of poo & tampons, lots of sickness from sea swimming.

Corvidsarethebest · Yesterday 22:07

I think if you said AIBU to move nearer to family, I think most people would think that reasonable. Moving to get more support, do more family things, to spend time with extended family is a good idea. I don't think you will necessarily get small class sizes though, my children were in Devon and they have the same pressure as everywhere on school places in good schools!

I think you need to work out what is doable and achievable of your dream, and what is basically a fantasy.

I can't think of anything less fantastic than home-schooling my children though, so we obviously have different fantasies, glad to send them to school!